News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by riscy on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:46AM (#11271756)
The ability for any software to reliably recognize whether an encryption algorithm is being performed or not is not possible (not computable). It can always be hidden.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by leeoniya on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:49AM (#11271768)
you don't need to detect encryption. with full memory access, you just take the plaintext.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by ntucker on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:10AM (#11271809)
My point is that you don't have to do the encryption on the device. You can send/store encrypted data via compromised devices and channels.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by mirimir on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:50AM (#11271984)
Yes. And you can obfuscate it. You can even encode it using packet timing, which is very hard to detect. It's also very inefficient, on the order of 1%, but that's enough for text over HD video. See True Names by Vernor Vinge.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by DanBC on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:54AM (#11272000)
You can't trust the device - it's compromised. So even if you use encryption with that compromised device the plain text still leaks.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by mirimir on Saturday March 12, 2016 @04:12AM (#11272048)
Not if the encrypted text was created on a trusted device.

Consider that, as it is now, encrypted data on the Internet traverses numerous untrusted devices.

For an extreme example, see https://github.com/maqp/tfc-otp

Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by DanBC on Saturday March 12, 2016 @08:45AM (#11272824)
> Consider that, as it is now, encrypted data on the Internet traverses numerous untrusted devices

And those untrusted devices leak considerable amounts of that data! You know that it doesn't matter how good the encryption is if one of the computers in the chain is full of malware.

I genuinely don't understand the point you're making, especially in reference to this parent: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11271745

For your OTP example: I know what the cipher text is. I slurped that. I don't know what the key is, or the plain text is, until you decrypt it, at which point I know both because I have access to your memory because your computer is compromised.

Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by mirimir on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:57PM (#11275576)
My point is that compartmentalization allows secure communication through untrusted devices. It won't be convenient, but it's doable. There is no "computer". There are local networks of suitably isolated devices.

The device that decrypts can't send anything to the Internet, because it's behind receive-only optoisolators. The device that encrypts can't receive anything from the Internet, because it's behind send-only optoisolators. All intervening information processing may occur in your head. Or there may be other devices that are totally air-gapped, with all data transfer through single use flash storage. If you're using entirely untrusted devices, you move all crypto to such air-gapped devices.

It does help if these devices can be trusted, but that's not essential. You could, for example, do encryption manually with one-time pads. Or use that thing with decks of cards.

Maybe you claim that no trustable devices will be available. But that's unlikely. Consider how easy it is to obtain Afghani heroin in NYC. Also, if I were targeted by American adversaries, I could arguably trust devices backdoored by the Russians, or the North Koreans, etc. And vice versa.

Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by plugnburn on Saturday March 12, 2016 @09:31AM (#11273007)
There still are some encryption schemes that can be run with nothing more than a pencil and paper. See SMSPP for example: https://gist.github.com/plugnburn/6b50ceee3a89893a9e48

You can also use straddling checkerboards if you can do some very simple math.