Animals have a greatly inhibited sense of consciousness and continuity. They deserve respect as a resource, but they don't deserve "rights" of any kind.
I come from India where we literally and figuratively worship plethora to animal gods. We made our bullocks work like slaves in our field and yet for us they were members of family. Humans in the house-hold did not start their food until the Animals were served their food first. Same for temple elephants, bullfight bulls, snakes etc. it was a relationship that both used Animals and yet respected them for their "life".
In last decade or so a lot of western funded NGOs are on prowl painting all Hindu traditions as "exploitative towards animals" demanding ban on almost everything from bull-fights to temple elephants.
Solutions sometimes exist in plain sight but we refuse to look.
If nothing can consume anything else then life can't exist.
I'd argue that their ethical standards are wholly separate from our own. For humans, self-preservation as a race is very important.
If you don't eat living things, that leaves milk and honey.
I'm not saying "become X-ist". I'm saying that in order for us to live, others must die. Plants, animals and others aren't inherently worth more or less than we humans. But it's our responsibility to remember their sacrifices so we could continue.
Failing to draw a line between two things doesn't mean that they are the same. Plants do not possess a nervous system capable of metacognition. Killing and eating a plant is not the same thing as killing and eating a mammal, bird, or fish.
> Plants do not possess a nervous system capable of metacognition.
Scientists aren't so sure. And we're only finding out more chemical 'sensors' that allow different sensing of our environment. As for a nervous net, it was thought "No"... But again, more study shows that it's not true.
http://www.pri.org/stories/2014-01-09/new-research-plant-int...
http://www.dw.com/en/when-plants-say-ouch/a-510552-1
http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20141111-plants-have-a-hidden...
> Killing and eating a plant is not the same thing as killing and eating a mammal, bird, or fish.
That's just moralizing. There is no basis in which to say that X life is better or worse than Y life.
>That's just moralizing. There is no basis in which to say that X life is better or worse than Y life.
Did I say anything about morality? No. Did I say that plant lives were "worse", or animal lives were "better"? No. I said killing a plant was different than killing a mammal. Do you disagree with that assertion?
Edit: Killing a plant might be more similar to killing off chunks of an organism's brain cells. As such it may be ethical to kill individual plants assuming we maintain the integrity of any existing colonies.
1. Feel
2. Learn
3. Respond to pain
4. Not respond to pain if under anaesthesia
5. Chemically whimper if they are sick
6. Communicate
... That there might be something deeper? Where is your sense of scientific inquiry that the previously held beliefs are potentially wrong?Would you want to be able to open up a line of communication if it were indeed possible?
Because something has a higher order nervous system does that mean we have to assign it equal rights? How high an order of system would be required to have equal rights? Why does it really matter how something else feels other than members of our own species?
For the record I generally agree with not keeping killer whales in captivity. I'm just asking the question so we know the position has been well considered.
Perhaps "slavery" is a bit too strong? (And that's without even getting into "you say that like it's a bad thing....").