There's a great difference between a photocopy in a safe and a photo of ID on the internet. The one in the safe is much harder to steal in bulk.
Many home insurance claims in the UK are not paid: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-35401104
There are plenty of cases of people in the UK being robbed by eg cleaners and insurance doesn't pay.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05qvn36
> Last week Money Box heard from a listener who was surprised to find that her home contents insurance did not cover her for theft by a cleaner. Money Box listeners have told us that insurers seem confused about whether you are covered if carers and home helps steal from you. An insurance expert tells Money Box how you can find out.
(They misuse the word "carer" here, which should only be used about people who provide unpaid care. They mean something like "care worker".)
> Some examples of what the Host Protection Insurance program doesn’t cover:
> Intentional acts where liability isn’t the result of an accident.
EG, theft.
But i was really referencing AirBnB insurance....
I'm claiming people are seeking avoidance. People would rather have the deterrent effect, so that they might avoid the hassles of going through claims and then waiting for things to be righted.
As an engineer I get the privacy concerns so I'm split on which way I sit on this fence but I trust in a large tech company like AirBnB to get security right - so on balance the short term risks of someone abusing my flat outweigh my long term risks of someone getting my passport data.