Re:Google did something seriously wrong
by orangecat on Sunday February 14, 2010 @10:57PM
(#1125851)
It was not at all obvious that "create a public profile" was equivalent to "make public the people who I frequently email". Certainly it's much more complex than telling the difference between ReadWriteWeb and Facebook, in which case there was a great deal of sympathy for the clueless users.
Yes, and I think Google was too cavalier in how they flagged that up -- the current revisions are much better.
But nonetheless, it doesn't mean they forced people's data public, and it doesn't mean the NYT should have reported that as fact, as Winer demands. It's more nuanced than that, and only hit-seeking shouty tech blogs are saying otherwise. It'd be a disservice to their readers and the truth for the NYT to take their piece to the same histronic level as this link.
There are millions of gmail users who haven't done this, and consequently have no public profile, and no information exposed. Users were not forced into anything. Buzz is there and inviting, sure, but I read the screen and was well aware of what would happen.
(Compare Facebook, which did recently force its users into publicising their names, small profile image and contacts list, with nary a whimper. It was a much more complicated opt-out box, too)