Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by DavidSJ on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @06:55AM
(#11252398)
I didn't say AlphaGo is essentially the same as Deep Q Networks. I said the convolutional neural network part of it is essentially the same. We agree that the integration of that CNN into the rest of the system is very different.
Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by Houshalter on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @02:56PM
(#11255350)
It's best to say that alphago uses neural networks, which are extremely general. The same way planes and cars both use internal combustion engines. ICEs are extremely general. They produce mechanical energy from gas, and are totally uncaring whether you put them into a plane or a car. The body of the plane is necessary, but isn't really the interesting part.
Likewise NNs are uncaring what application you put them into. Give them a different input and a different goal, and they will learn to do that instead. Alphago gave it's NN's control over a monte carlo search tree, and that turned out to be enough to beat Go. They could plug the same AI into a car and it would learn to control that instead.
Note that even without the monte carlo search system, it was able to beat most amateurs, and predict the moves experts would make most of the time.
Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by argonaut on Wednesday March 09, 2016 @04:27PM
(#11255846)
Even without the neural net system, AI is able to beat most amateurs, and predict moves experts would make.
Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by Houshalter on Thursday March 10, 2016 @02:23PM
(#11261481)
I'm not sure that's correct. MCTS has well known weaknesses, and isn't even a predictive algorithm. MCTS on it's own couldn't get anywhere near beating the top Go champion, that requires deepminds neural networks.
Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by argonaut on Friday March 11, 2016 @07:55AM
(#11266304)
http://www.milesbrundage.com/blog-posts/alphago-and-ai-progr...
The best Go program before AlphaGo was CrazyStone, ranked at 5-dan ("high amateur" range).
Re:AlphaGo beats the world champion Lee Sedol in first of fi...
by Houshalter on Friday March 11, 2016 @03:25PM
(#11269241)
There's a massive skill difference between ameatures and professionals. It couldn't even beat the top ameatures.
While the higher portions do share some similarities with the Atari system, at a basic level this is a machine that was designed and trained to play Go. AlphaGO is 'essentially the same' as the Atari system in the same way that all Neural Networks are 'essentially the same.'
Is this an extremely impressive accomplishment? Yes. However, doesn't seem to qualify as anything close to generalizable.
[1] http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2016/01/alphago-mastering...