Is it really all we need? Or it is more that they threw a lot of hardware to it? What if if a part of its efficiency is because they threw a lot of GPUs with a huge network, rather than having a NN efficient by itself?
We see that: "AlphaGos Elo when it beat Fan Hui was 3140 using 1202 CPUs and 176 GPUs. Lee Sedol has an equivalent Elo to 3515 on the same scale (Elos on different scales aren't directly comparable). For each doubling of computer resources AlphaGo gains about 60 points of Elo."
It's a lot of hardware.
It is the same question for the data they used. Facebook, Google and others seem to agree that, at the end, the quantity and quality of data are more important than the algorithm itself. So how much is it at play here? Knowing that will be able to show us why it is performing well and how much we can appreciate their work.
Basically, the ("lots of hardware") distributed implementation gets ~3100 points in the Elo rating against ~2900. ~2900 is still sufficient to win against Fan Hui. So I would say, that yes, this algorithm has most of the merit here.
What if you train an AI to play an RTS where matter, energy, and time are the resources and the goal is to take over the world?
Monte Carlo Tree Search was necessary and itself a massive improvement over minimax but not sufficient for creating a Go program to challenge professional players. The true innovation here is the neural networks. Without those networks to guide it AlphaGo plays far worse than existing programs.
The fact that those networks are sufficient is pretty incredible. We already knew that by inventing them we had created a very pure form of pattern recognition, but it's surprising that the pattern recognition coupled with some tree search seems to be all you need to play Go as well as humans.
It's not impressive to you that we've now reproduced a piece of human intelligence, "intuition", which was previously considered out of reach?