Re:Ask HN: Where can I get constructive criticism for my app...
by brudgers on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @02:28PM
(#11247812)
Everything on the damn internet is forever...fortunately it helps with discoverability.
Anyway, where I was going is that everything that is in your comment here provides context and most importantly is interesting to the people who are likely to read it:
1. It's technical
2. It's on HN
Making a website that gets feedback on a website review website is...well it's like those big books of 1000 new house plans. The plans are optimized for selling from a big book of house plans, not for the buyer's lot or lifestyle or around their love of amphibians and British motorcycles. And everyone has their own amphibians-and-british-motorcycles crush and there's no way to know it without talking to them.
So what I'm saying is that the hard part is figuring out what someone cares about. I mean even a website about designing websites around set logic and relativism has at least one person who cares...so does british-motorcycles-and-amphibians because I went to Junior High School with her.
The challenge is that it is a lot easier to find people, like me, to comment on a british-motorcycles-and-amphibians website than it is to build one that my friend will care about.
Anyway, where I was going is that everything that is in your comment here provides context and most importantly is interesting to the people who are likely to read it:
Making a website that gets feedback on a website review website is...well it's like those big books of 1000 new house plans. The plans are optimized for selling from a big book of house plans, not for the buyer's lot or lifestyle or around their love of amphibians and British motorcycles. And everyone has their own amphibians-and-british-motorcycles crush and there's no way to know it without talking to them.So what I'm saying is that the hard part is figuring out what someone cares about. I mean even a website about designing websites around set logic and relativism has at least one person who cares...so does british-motorcycles-and-amphibians because I went to Junior High School with her.
The challenge is that it is a lot easier to find people, like me, to comment on a british-motorcycles-and-amphibians website than it is to build one that my friend will care about.