To take your even more specific example of delivery trucks, someone has got to deliver the food that everyone eats. You can't arbitrarily assign the total resultant negative externalities to whichever companies own and operate them.
6. Eduardo Castro-Wright, Vice Chairman; President and CEO, Wal-Mart Stores U.S. Division $9,987,493 total compensation
8. Thomas M. Schoewe, EVP and CFO, Wal-Mart $9,477,584 total compensation
16. C. Douglas McMillon, EVP; President and CEO, Wal-Mart International Division $8,191,857 total compensation
Four out of the 20 "Highest Paid Retail Executives" are Wal-Mart executives.
Source: http://www.risnews.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=...
Why not? There's a big difference between retail and food, especially in the US. Food can be grown and delivered locally, and agriculture can be optimized for certain climates. Retail products, however, almost always require far more distance had between the producer and the consumer.
Roads are a great example, because even after that cargo hold of plastic GI Joes "Made in China" lands on the coast, Wal-Mart trucks still have to drive hundreds or thousands of miles get the product delivered to its target consumers in rural "agriculture" lands on the interior of the US.
Wal-Mart is the extreme example, but if I remember from my MBA classes, it's fairly simple to point out where the company has exploited almost everything it could legally exploit. It undercuts competitors in almost every one of its new locations; predatory pricing puts mom-and-pop shops out of business. How is this a good thing?
Either you take as a given that people will buy that GIJoe from China or they won't. If they will, some company is going to provide it; in your case it just happens to be Walmart. If the consumer won't buy it, no retailer will provide it.
If your argument is that we should attempt to assign economic penalties (taxes, if you will) on the externalities such that the true cost of those is reflected in the fuel that Walmart (and everyone else) buys, I'm all for it. If you're suggesting that the most appropriate way to correct for those externalities is to raise the income taxes on the Walmart execs who appear on the "top 20 retailer execs" list, I don't see even a tenuous connection with which I can agree.
Those are all (cause -> problem -> money for solution) dependencies. I don't see why you want to get money from a company owner to solve any of them....
Not exactly. They're
(Problem -> Root Cause -> Solution) "dependencies". The very nature of negative externalities is that they're problems that societies have to deal with when one entity decides to profit at the detriment of his neighbors.
Here's an example of "negative externalities" that is actually true, and took place near a town where I used to live.
Assume: You're a property owner, and you don't want Pig Farm, INC to buy the parcel next to you and put up a pig farm because of the smell, potential health problems due to the (literally) toxic waste, etc. Yeah, there are regulations, but Pig Farm, INC has figured out that if it has a facility with 99 instead of 100 pigs that it can skirt the laws.
Problem: Pig waste is toxic, and causes health problems that you're beginning to notice is affecting your children. Root Cause: There's a pig farm next door to your house. Solution: Move. Or get the pig farm move.
Problem: You were there first. Why should you move? Besides, you can't afford to move because you're behind on doctor bills resultant from the toxic pig farm emissions. Root Cause: Doctor bills coupled with the fact that nobody will buy your house because it's next to a pig farm. Solution: Take the loss on your house and move anyway; health benefits outweigh the desire to hold on to your property in a place that is making you and your family sick.
Problem: Pig Farm, INC bulldozes the house you used to live on and builds another facility, which conveniently holds 99 pigs. What used to be just your problem is now your former neighbor's problem.
In summary, it's not about "money for the solution" it's about an "equitable solution". If one farm in town is causing 95 percent of the town's health problems, and causing loss of equity to 98 percent of its residents, that's a good thing only for the CEO of Pig Farm, INC who's raking in the money with the increased salary due to demand for bacon and pork and sausage.
2. "that's a good thing only for the CEO of Pig Farm, INC who's raking in the money with the increased salary due to demand for bacon and pork and sausage" - and for local community which gains work places, and for local shops that may offer lower prices due to lower transportation costs, and to the local services since Pig Farm INC needs a new road so the trucks don't break, and ...
If you're arguing for taxing people at differential rates based on something besides income, fine. But don't confuse 'income' with 'strain on the national infrastructure' or anything else.
Doesn't the USA have corporate tax? Shouldn't corporate tax (and things such as fuel levies and business levies) pay for the cost of roads?
Taxes that a corporation pays in the course of doing business (fuel, payroll, etc) are presumably NOT allocated in this fashion.
Actually, yes, I think it is reasonable. The top 1% earners typically are CEOs of large corporations, celebrities, or professional athletes. In any event, their brands put more strain on the overall infrastructure than a little janitor who is in the bottom one percent of income earners.
The CEO of Wal-Mart has, at any given time, thousands of delivery trucks on the roads, trucks that contribute to traffic congestion, increase the risk of accidents, cause potholes, and spit out harmful emissions into the atmosphere. The negative externalities born by society can be assigned a cost, and (even though it's by far from a perfect system), it does make sense for those who use/abuse the system for personal profit to be taxed more.