News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by pc86 on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @09:14AM (#11245290)
Your argument is "we don't want more old people because I disagree with them ideologically." Shoddy at best.
Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by slavik81 on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @10:11AM (#11245653)
That's not it. The problem is that individuals have cognitive biases. People rarely change their minds. As a society, this is offset by a slow, regular replacement of its members.

If you end that cycle of renewal, the rate at which our society reacts to change and adopts new ideas would significantly slow.

That's a problem regardless of how well the society aligns with my ideals.

Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by habitue on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @12:50PM (#11246988)
People's brains change as they age. There are definite differences between the way older people and younger people think. This isn't a generalization about old people having bad politics, but rather a comment on the tendency of people's minds to be harder to change over time.

Personally, I think one of the biggest challenges to transitioning to a low-birthrate, ultra-long-lived society is that a constant influx of young blood seems to be a necessary engine for new ideas and progress. There's a combination of not knowing better[1] and not having as much to lose that makes young people more willing to take big risks and push for more egalitarian societies over time. Left to their own devices, accumulation of wealth and status tend to ossify people's belief systems and reduce their incentives to throw everything out and start over.

[1] by this I mean not having the same accumulated beliefs about what is best. Sometimes those beliefs turn out to be unfounded, and you discover that by challenging them.

Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by forgotpasswd3x on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @09:21AM (#11245343)
If you re-read the post, that's actually not his argument.
Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by pc86 on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @09:25AM (#11245360)
He's saying that the older someone is the more their ideology defines them, which is itself probably inaccurate. And he says that that "could be a problem."
Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by talideon on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @10:08AM (#11245631)
He's arguing about ideological stagnation. That's bad regardless of just about what the ideology is and whether you agree with the particular.

To quote Max Planck, "Science progresses one funeral at a time." That's as true of anything as it is of science.

Re:If you're alive in 30 years you might be in 1000 years too by forgotpasswd3x on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @09:37AM (#11245438)
Right, but that's different than saying he doesn't like old people because he disagrees with them.