News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by tehwebguy on Monday March 07, 2016 @06:15PM (#11242487)
That is not what I've read, but rather it merely allows Apple to match lower prices elsewhere for the same product, so I still don't see how this could be price fixing.
Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by dilemma on Monday March 07, 2016 @07:09PM (#11242716)
Apple used MFN to ensure that nobody sold the same books for less, fixing prices at a higher level.
Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by acqq on Monday March 07, 2016 @07:14PM (#11242738)
How did it "ensure"? The publishers were absolutely able to sell at Amazon and Apple for 9.99 if they wanted, but they didn't.

The publishers even before Apple arrived tried various steps to change their deals with Amazon and let it sell for more, they just haven't had any negotiation power.

From the court document:

"Well aware of the Publishers’ experimentation with windowing, Apple also told Publishers that it opposed windowing; it believed that withholding e-books alienated customers and led to piracy."

It was one attempt of the publishers before.

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by dilemma on Monday March 07, 2016 @07:33PM (#11242812)
Their power to negotiate came from the collusion that Apple orchestrated.

This makes it very clear: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/07/10/a-jud...

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by acqq on Monday March 07, 2016 @07:37PM (#11242824)
The fact that the prices raised doesn't prove anything to me (that's the only thing I see in the article). Of course the publishers got more power with the new store. Of course they wanted to sell at higher prices even before Apple appeared, but couldn't, because Amazon didn't have real competition. What was Apple supposed to do? To open the exact same store as Amazon? Why?

And how was Apple doing anything what the publishers didn't do themselves? The CEO's had their meetings without Apple, even before, as I've already quoted. And after the meetings with Cue, they continued. Cue didn't organize them:

"After Young had met with Apple but before S&S had its meeting, Young could not resist calling Reidy to share the wonderful news that the “Top Man” at Apple opposed $9.99 pricing. He hesitated to say more because S&S would be meeting with Apple the following day, and he did not want to “spoil [the] fun.”"

It's obvious the publishers communicated, but I don't see Apple's guilt.

All my quotes here and in other posts here are from the court decision.

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by takeda on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:38PM (#11243235)
Here is explanation how it worked: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/07/10/a-jud...

If that still did not convince you, then I don't see the point discussing it further.

Note that antitrust laws are there to protect consumers.

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by jsprogrammer on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:12PM (#11243156)
Have you read Steve's email[0]? He was colluding with other players to set prices in plain text.

[0] http://allthingsd.com/20130515/heres-that-steve-jobs-e-book-...

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by acqq on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @03:52AM (#11244176)
Like the author of that text, I find the context (publishers wanting different pricing for best-sellers even before Apple and the entrance of Apple to the market that breaks the Amazon's monopoly, Apple be willing to sell the way the publishers prefer) actually important.
Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by jsprogrammer on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @02:06PM (#11247641)
"Our proposal does set the upper limit for ebook retail pricing..."

It's like it was written as an admission.

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by Oletros on Tuesday March 08, 2016 @12:17AM (#11243677)
> All my quotes here and in other posts here are from the court decision.

All of your quotes here and in other posts are cherry picking form the court decision to much your beliefs.

Read the 160 pages of the ruling and then post. But it seems that nothing will change your views

Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by fpgeek on Monday March 07, 2016 @09:45PM (#11243256)
As I understand it, the core problem is that when Apple price-matches, the 70/30 split between the publisher and Apple doesn't change. If the other retailer (e.g. Amazon) has the freedom to set their prices via the wholesale model, the publisher will start making less money in the iBookstore (and any other "agency MFN" retailers, which eventually included Nook as a willing participant) on any book that retailer chooses to discount, even though the publisher has no control over that price. To avoid this problem, each publisher has to switch all of their retailers to the agency model - giving up the extra money they make when a wholesale retailer charges their customer a discounted price but pays the publisher the full wholesale price in return for greater control over the prices the final customers pay.
Re:​Apple gets smacked by $450M e-book price-fixing fine by acqq on Monday March 07, 2016 @06:24PM (#11242522)
> it merely allows Apple to match lower prices elsewhere for the same product

Exactly, and I quote the exact formulation of MFN from the court's decision in my other (possibly harder to read) comment here.