Re:‘They Don’t Make These Anymore’: Maintaining the MBTA’s 1...
by Animats on Monday March 07, 2016 @06:06PM
(#11242452)
For a century, replacements were not much of a problem. Most of the components were either from Union Switch and Signal, or General Railway Signal, both in the US, and they still made them. Then US&S (which used to have www.switch.com [1]) was sold to Ansaldo and then to Hitachi, and General Railway Signal was acquired by Alstom. Alstom continues to make some GRS relays.[2] But not the whole line of them. Ansaldo offers a remanufacturing service for the older components.
The New York City system uses mostly General Railway Signal components, while Boston uses US&S. NYC had to rebuild old relays after the big flood a few years ago, because all available spare stocks, both theirs and the manufacturers', had been exhausted. But they were able to get new ones from Alstom over time. Boston seems to be having more of a parts problem.
These relay-based systems are designed to fail safe, in a very literal way. "Vital" relays (the ones in safety-critical circuits) open by gravity, and the open direction is always towards a red signal. Broken wires always force things towards a safer condition. This is not a property of computer-based systems. There are modern replacements, such as Ansaldo MicroLok II, which are programmable logic controllers which emulate relay systems.[5]
These, unfortunately, can be Internet-connected.[6]
Here's a simulator for a GRS relay-based signaling system, down to the relay level.[7]
The New York City system uses mostly General Railway Signal components, while Boston uses US&S. NYC had to rebuild old relays after the big flood a few years ago, because all available spare stocks, both theirs and the manufacturers', had been exhausted. But they were able to get new ones from Alstom over time. Boston seems to be having more of a parts problem.
These relay-based systems are designed to fail safe, in a very literal way. "Vital" relays (the ones in safety-critical circuits) open by gravity, and the open direction is always towards a red signal. Broken wires always force things towards a safer condition. This is not a property of computer-based systems. There are modern replacements, such as Ansaldo MicroLok II, which are programmable logic controllers which emulate relay systems.[5] These, unfortunately, can be Internet-connected.[6]
Here's a simulator for a GRS relay-based signaling system, down to the relay level.[7]
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20080103132002/http://www.switch... [2] http://alstomsignalingsolutions.com/OurProducts/WaysideProdu... [3] http://www.rrsignalpix.com/grs_relays.html [4] http://www.ansaldo-sts.com/en/about-us/ansaldo-around-world/... [5] http://www.ansaldo-sts.com/sites/ansaldosts.message-asp.com/... [6] http://www.westermo.com/web/web_en_idc_com.nsf/AllDocuments/... [7] http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/NXSYS,_Signalling_and_Interloc...