News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by NoGravitas on Monday March 07, 2016 @01:53PM (#11240699)
I suspect "Just ignore the licences and focus on the technology" is not going to fly with enterprise customers.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by VonGuard on Monday March 07, 2016 @01:59PM (#11240746)
Totally correct. However, it may fly just fine with Ubuntu's "just install a damn Linux and get the app online" crowd. Ubuntu makes Linux easy to install and maintain, and that could be enough for some users. They only need one or two giant apps to grow here in order for it to be called a success.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by adamleventhal on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:01PM (#11240761)
"As with anything, evaluate the technology, evaluate the risks, and move on."

I've been selling to enterprise customers for a little while now. All technology has risk, new technology and the status quo alike. Companies weigh those risks against the expected benefits. Some folks will obviously avoid the brouhaha completely; it makes sense. Others will decide that the benefits outweigh the risk; there's nothing less comprehensible about that decision.

Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by _ph_ on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:09PM (#11240811)
No, the licenses are not ignored. Both, the GPL and the CDDL require the source available for any copy of the resulting program distributed. In that spirit, there is no license violation. There is some disagreement to which extend linking programs under those licenses is technically possible. But the verdict is still out, whether this is a problem at all. But for the goals both licenses aim for - open source which stay open source, is not violated. This is not a company shipping a closed source executable based on modified sources. They are just shipping precompiled binaries based on available sources.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by yarrel on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:16PM (#11240853)
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by jra_samba on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:01PM (#11240759)
Yep. It's all fun and games until the lawsuits start :-).

I don't understand people like this. If they were advocating using pirate copies of Microsoft Windows or other proprietary software, would they be saying "ignore Microsoft legal department and focus on how cool it is that I get a free copy of Windows ?

Stupid, stupid, stupid.

Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by kbenson on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:08PM (#11240809)
I don't think that's a relevant comparison at all. What we have here is two open source technologies that have traditionally been kept from being used together because of specific clauses in their licenses, and some lawyers who have looked at it and are vouching that it's not a problem. That's far from ignoring the proprietary closed source, for-profit licensing of a product where it's very clear cut. The lawyers may be wrong, and it's probably a good idea for enterprise customers to steer clear, but the whole point is that there is some valid contention over whether the technologies can be used together. There is not valid contention over whether you can use Windows without a license.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by brazzledazzle on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:11PM (#11240828)
I think it's safe to say there's a world of difference between license violations for a piece of software that's closed source, proprietary and sold for profit and a license incompatibility on two open source projects caused by a single clause in licenses that are otherwise compatible.

You may have the chops and cred to call someone stupid that wrote dtrace but I'd certainly hesitate before doing so myself.

Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by jra_samba on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:33PM (#11240976)
People can be very smart technically, yet legally very naive. This is a very naive legal position, which I certainly feel justified in calling "stupid, stupid, stupid".
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by brazzledazzle on Monday March 07, 2016 @03:12PM (#11241264)
Certainly if I was a lawyer I'd probably feel comfortable using an insult like "stupid" to describe a legal position but I'm not. You might be, I don't know. But it's still unnecessarily negative.
Re:Big News for ZFS on Linux by adamleventhal on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:04PM (#11240776)
Lots of people do exactly that. In fact, many companies even use software for which the licenses have lapsed or they never owned licenses in the first place. Sometimes it's by accident; in other cases it's a knowing acceptance of risk.