Re:DIY Neurostimulation on the rise
by gherkin0 on Monday March 07, 2016 @12:39PM
(#11240198)
Yeah, this tool seems like a pretty blunt instrument at this point. From the OP:
> It is very difficult to target a specific region of the brain, especially with simple home set-ups that use wet sponges as the contact points.
My layman's speculation is that things like cognition have complicated and fine-granted regulatory systems associated with them, which may have sub-optimal set-points for many people. To get true "cognitive enhancement" you'd have to 1) influence these systems in precise targeted ways (i.e. not with a blunt instrument) and 2) do it in a way that won't trigger counteracting regulation. Anything less would probably cause side-effects and/or be temporary with negative withdrawal symptoms.
Re:DIY Neurostimulation on the rise
by nkrisc on Monday March 07, 2016 @01:02PM
(#11240341)
Pretty much. I don't want to discount the potential in this field of research, but I really don't think they're going to achieve much with DIY transcranial stimulation at this point.
> It is very difficult to target a specific region of the brain, especially with simple home set-ups that use wet sponges as the contact points.
My layman's speculation is that things like cognition have complicated and fine-granted regulatory systems associated with them, which may have sub-optimal set-points for many people. To get true "cognitive enhancement" you'd have to 1) influence these systems in precise targeted ways (i.e. not with a blunt instrument) and 2) do it in a way that won't trigger counteracting regulation. Anything less would probably cause side-effects and/or be temporary with negative withdrawal symptoms.