Re:Returning multiple values from functions in C++
by adwf on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:06PM
(#11240793)
Yeah, that's how I do it sometimes with other peoples code. But with my own code I much prefer using structs. Makes it much clearer to read and there is little implicit structure like with an ordered list. So my preferred way would look more like:
(let ((struct (my-get-decoded-time)))
(format t "Year: ~A~%Seconds: ~A" (time-year struct) (time-seconds struct)))
With the original multiple value return, if there were a bug and I were reviewing the code, I'd need to also review get-decoded-time and see what order the values are in. If instead it returned structured data, I could skip that step as the values are clear.Lisp is still my favourite language. I generally rank languages by how much time/code I'm spending managing the language versus managing the problem I want to solve. Lisp is very good for that, very little cruft so it lets you focus directly on the problem at hand.
There are libraries out there that provide syntactic sugar for Common Lisp, which is often discarded because (i) they define their own "ghetto" dialect of Lisp (ii) it is in fact not very important to waste a character or two. Aesthetics alone is not a goal.
For multiple values, you might still use a list instead, in which case you are back to the usual way of accessing data:
If you only want to access a particular value, use "nth-value" (not possible in your example, of course).