Also Saint Lucia doesn't have the clout as India when it comes to global trade.
For example, when Novartis lost the case, in Indian supreme courts, to ban the production of Gleevec (a Cancer drug) by Indian generic makers, they could've taken the arbitration to the WTO. However, this would mean terrible PR for both Novartis and US. Instead, PhRMA (a trade group for big pharma) and Novartis decided to let this one lie.
However, the US did recently challenge India's decision to force LCR (local content requirement) in it's push to use more solar energy in the country. USA, which is one of the biggest exporters of solar panels to India, successfully fought this decision.
I feel, in the end, the WTO is like any other court where two big conglomerates go head-to-head. Each one does not want to piss off the other to a great extent. And settlements are preferred over outright fights.
Simple answer: The US will invade that country in no time, or give millions or billions of dollars to support those against the Government in the country to instability the country.
They do it with Syria(they gave hundreds of millions of dollars in weapons to "moderate rebels" to start a war against Assad, Saudi Arabia gave billions or Ukraine(they gave 6 billion dollars to opposition), that are reasonable big countries. They can wipe out any small country that dare to go against US national interest.
With India, South Africa there was death threats, and killings,lots of money under the table and blackmailing of people in Government and finally economic sanctions.
If someone puts something on a paper it does not matter unless that someone has the means to protect what is in the paper.
Native Indians had the right to own the American land because it was the land of their fathers and grandfathers but the white man had repetition rifles and railroads.
Could legal action be taken? If Saint Lucia signed a treaty that defined rules for such an action.
Also, selling a drug for any price smells an awful lot like capitalism. Some folks would rather the government set prices. Hey, I wonder what happens if a company sells bad drugs that hurts people? The government should impose regulations. Hrm I bet that would drive costs up. Maybe drug companies need some financial incentives to help cover those costs? .... Wait a second!
India has a long history of Non Alignment and trade blockades going back 50 years.... but most importantly has huge economic leverage right now, only second to China (in Asia).
In fact, my personal bet is on Iran to be able to do something like this - they have a sizeable youth and good education systems... as well as a long history of leverage against the west . If only they get rid of their religious constitution.
Apply that to any situation in any country in the middle east.
It would also amount to state endorsed IP theft.
As opposed to what we do when we invade and bomb/drone other countries? As opposed to what we did when we engineer coups in resource rich countries? Come on. Let me guess, you're buying into the idea that generics hurt RnD. Let me assure you, having worked briefly in a pharma RnD lab, the bulk of big pharmas expenditures are on marketing and bribes, NOT RnD. Here's a recent headline: http://www.statnews.com/pharmalot/2016/02/22/novartis-south-...
You'll find similar bribery cases with GSK, Pfizer, etc.
> As opposed to what we do when we invade and bomb/drone other countries?
I don't think the parent supports the action, but merely stating the likely outcome, realpolitik and all. S/he is answering gp's question: "What is stopping some other countries (even micro-nations) from instituting a policy that forfeits all patents on medication"
The answer, in short, is leverage: smaller countries can be pressured into not even considering it - because of the consequences. India can do this because it is better able to withstand the hypothetical political pressure.
Not to mention that every single Pharma company would stop all R&D investment in about 5 seconds.
Would you invest your own money in a Pharma company if there were no drug patents?
India does not disagree with drug patents, from the article: "Successive governments have taken a view that patents should be granted only for major innovations, not updates to existing compounds."
Pharma companies are notorious for extending patents (in perpetuity) by adding small 'updates' to existing compounds when the patent nears expiry. This is rather similar to Disney's strategy: get copyright period extended right before Mickey Mouse is about to enter the public domain.
And in one way or another someone has to pay for R&D.
https://www.kent.ac.uk/law/ip/resources/ip_dissertations/200...
Taxpayers?
Whose money? The investor's?
"Maybe we should take the money and directly fund research and make the results free for everyone."
And that would be more efficient than letting companies compete for funding from investors?
It might also have the side effect that we'd get more drugs that are currently not produced because it wouldn't profitable (eg antibiotics) and fewer drugs with dubious efficacy that are very profitable (eg anti-depressants).
I say that business works extraordinarily well with science and is superior to eg government research by a great margin. As proven by Bell Labs, IBM research, Xerox PARC, Microsoft research, Google, Lockheed, Apple, Shockley, Intel, Fairchild, Samsung, Cisco, Texas Instruments, Boeing, Pfizer, Merck, Amgen, Gilead, Genentech, Standard Oil (one of the first highly successful commercial research labs), and thousands of other corporations. Even if those companies didn't always capitalize on their research, they produced tremendous science. The technology lead the US has enjoyed for most of a century proves this fact, as it is heavily (not solely) derived from the scientific output of its corporations.
The US became by far the world leader on pharma and biotech specifically because a business, profit-seeking approach to those industries produces a dramatically greater outcome in terms of innovation.
If that weren't the case, the US would be dead last in pharma and biotech over the last 50 years, given its market approach.
And on your point, do governments distort science less than business?
Between someone motivated purely by profit, and a politician, I trust the profit-driven person far more. Their intentions are completely clear unlike a politician's.
It gets even trickier when you add global warming, abortion, mental health, etc. into the options.
Lets say you take the country of Saint Lucia- Could they not spur the economy (among the lowest in the world by GDP) by saying any company can manufacture any existing drug and sell it? I feel like the medical tourism for that could be extreme, especially since there is still many treatments india still does respect the patent for.
If the country put it in their constitution that all drugs should be a human right, could a legal action be taken against the country itself? I imagine the only recourse would be the pharma companies trying to force legislation in other countries to bring sanctions, but I think that would be a hard sell.