News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 by chris_wot on Monday March 07, 2016 @01:41AM (#11237476)
1. Be more precise. You want the cardinality of the set of items of the array. When you say you want the "size", you sound like you want to know the physical size in bytes of the array.

But yes, it would be good. But if you want to know why that macro is so problematic, have a read of the following:

http://blog.natekohl.net/making-countof-suck-less/

Of course, knowing how many elements are in an array is probably not a bad feature. (just noticed that porges points out that it's coming in C++17)

2. Completely agree with you on enums. There is a proposal in C++17 to allow for this, see:

http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2015/n442...

  std::enum_traits<E>::enumerators::size
  The number of enumerators in the enumerator list of E.
3. Same deal, see in the same proposal:

  std::enum_traits<E>::enumerators::get<I>::identifier
  A std::string_literal(N4121) holding the identifier of the enumerator. 
  The identifier is encoded in UTF­8 format, with any UCNs decoded.
3. #pragma once... the entire way of including headers into code is kind of broken. Having to implement a compilation firewall (aka pImpl) just to ensure that when you change a private member definition you need to recompile all other classes that rely on it seems so incredibly broken to me.

The LibreOffice code is littered with pImpls. It doesn't make it easier to read or understand the code, or even maintain it, at least in IMO. And without them, the compilation time is huge, every time I touch VCL code in anger I fear I'm wasting some other poor devs time in compilation time.

4. C99 designators - no opinion on this.

5. Binary - only if you can specify endianness.

6. FourCC doesn't seem like something for a standard... maybe that's just me though.

7. All macro criticisms - someone just please implement another macro processor in the standard already!

8. Iterating fields - back to that C++17 proposal again:

  std::class_traits<C>::class_members::get<I>
  Requires: I >= 0 && I < size
  
  Provides information about the I’th (zero­indexed) public member
  of C that satisfies the above criteria, in declared order.
9. Breaking by default in switch statements... ugh. Lots may disagree with me though. That .. gcc extension is pretty cool though! Add that to the standard, by all means!

10. Agreed on strongly typed typedefs

11. See that C++17 proposal I linked to previously - I think that has everything you'd want! High time too.

Re:Ill-Advised C++ Rant, Part 2 by kayamon on Monday March 07, 2016 @02:14AM (#11237565)
Yep that sure looks like a fine C++17 proposal (although I didn't understand a word of how it would actually be implemented).

How much do you want to bet that it won't be accepted? :). Like a lot of the other good proposals (std::optional anyone...?) I wouldn't be surprised if it never sees the light of day.