Re:At an Academic Pressure Cooker, a Setback Turns Deadly
by narag on Saturday February 13, 2010 @08:33PM
(#1123923)
...or simply because her superiors were assholes
Really? I've had some of this kind, and even when I was in a very stressful personal situation, I've never even thought of resorting to any kind of violence, even less shooting anyone.
These cases seem to be caused by mental illness. I agree with the person you're answering to that trying to "explain" a shooting this way is plainly wrong.
Re:At an Academic Pressure Cooker, a Setback Turns Deadly
by timr on Saturday February 13, 2010 @10:36PM
(#1124088)
Regardless of what you've personally experienced, I would imagine that everyone has a limit, beyond which they lose control of their emotions. It happens.
The question of whether this is called "mental illness" is open for debate. As far as I'm concerned, it's an academic question, unless the distinction can somehow lead to prevention of the act.
We don't know if this woman lost control because of mental illness, or stress in her personal life, or simply because her superiors were assholes. But if it's the latter, I'd rather hear a discussion about the ugly realities of academic life, than another cliché conversation demanding "respect and sympathy" from total strangers.