Re:CEO
by dahart on Sunday March 06, 2016 @11:04AM
(#11234183)
Personally, I think the proposed second example is too many commas, and does not improve the text. It adds a halting and pedantic feeling style to put 'and' in a clause by itself, for example, and arguably bad to separate 'self-inflicted' from 'largely'. It's not wrong, can be useful on occasion, is used frequently by some literary writers, but best avoided for general writing. You are making a purely stylistic suggestion, so this is completely subjective, but in my subjective opinion, the proposed fix is a net negative.
The writing in the article is very good, and generally speaking, the usage of commas is spot on throughout, in my opinion. But FWIW I did actually have to stop to parse one sentence that needed a comma to signal the intended meaning of the sentence. I wouldn't have even considered posting on the topic of commas were this thread not here, so, apologies.
I read the whole thing again twice, and couldn't find the sentence I tripped on, but I found a couple of examples to make my point, which is that the main reasons to care about commas are the non-stylistic scenarios where adding a comma changes the meaning of the sentence.
> Even so, no matter who advises you and no matter how insistent they are in the end the decisions are yours and yours alone and if there is a conflict between the direction that you think the company should go in or if there is second guessing of your decisions in the end your word is the one that matters.
This could easily be read:
> no matter how insistent they are in the end, the decisions are yours
But you probably were thinking:
> no matter how insistent they are, in the end the decisions are yours
Another one:
> If you are both a shareholder and a CEO note that these are two different roles
Since there's a condition followed by a suggestion, I would expect a separator between the clauses.
> If you are both a shareholder and a CEO, note that these are two different roles
The writing in the article is very good, and generally speaking, the usage of commas is spot on throughout, in my opinion. But FWIW I did actually have to stop to parse one sentence that needed a comma to signal the intended meaning of the sentence. I wouldn't have even considered posting on the topic of commas were this thread not here, so, apologies.
I read the whole thing again twice, and couldn't find the sentence I tripped on, but I found a couple of examples to make my point, which is that the main reasons to care about commas are the non-stylistic scenarios where adding a comma changes the meaning of the sentence.
> Even so, no matter who advises you and no matter how insistent they are in the end the decisions are yours and yours alone and if there is a conflict between the direction that you think the company should go in or if there is second guessing of your decisions in the end your word is the one that matters.
This could easily be read:
> no matter how insistent they are in the end, the decisions are yours
But you probably were thinking:
> no matter how insistent they are, in the end the decisions are yours
Another one:
> If you are both a shareholder and a CEO note that these are two different roles
Since there's a condition followed by a suggestion, I would expect a separator between the clauses.
> If you are both a shareholder and a CEO, note that these are two different roles