Are you having fun with making it? Make it, then. Make a damn good web site. If it's damn good, people will use it. You can make this a damn good web site, right? It's not going to be a shitpile? I'm asking seriously, not rhetorically. Generally quality is more important than anything; if you've got it, you're set.
If you're not making it for fun, then frankly, I don't know why you'd have bothered to start in the first place. You don't think you're going to get rich off something like this, I hope. If you're learning something by making this site, you can still learn by making.
Or did you do it just to see the results? Because you can see the results on ChatRoulette. If you think you can do better, stop asking us if a better product will be worth anything and start asking yourself if you can really do better. If it's better, in a way that people care about, they'll use it. If it's not, then nobody will even care enough to mock you.
Are you doing something meaningful with your time? Answer honestly. If you are, then I can't see why you'd ask us anything of this sort. If you're not, then get yourself together and do cool shit.
(Somebody who uses this site more translate what I said into Hacker Newspeak. Something something penetration adaptability futureexperience something tippingpoint gladwell rand.)
In your first paragraph, you've already made 3 excuses about why you haven't released anything:
- "I'm busy on other things in my life"
- "I chose some wrong technologies to get started with"
- "I'm not the best developer in the world"
You've got to cut that shit out right now. Let this be the last time you got jumped on an idea because somebody else was working his or her ass off on it, while you were making excuses.- Competitors are validation of the idea.
- The only way sites get the "wow" factor is through rapid iteration and contact with real users.
A week before we were set to launch, omegle.com came out which was the same thing - simpler - but essentially the same. We abandoned the idea immediately because the internet was abuzz with omegle's brilliant concept, and we'd be seen as imitators and won't get enough people interested.
One week, that's all we lost by. If I hadn't pushed for combing the site for security holes and writing in spam protection, over-optimizing the comet-server, etc, it would've been our site over there getting several hundred thousands of hits. This taught me the importance of releasing early and iterating and improving quickly.
Still, every time I see omegle.com in the news or other sites, I feel sad that it could have been us, but I also feel proud that I came up with, and implemented an idea which would've worked nevertheless.
(a) You don't get buzz just by getting something out there. Usually, nobody cares when you launch, no matter how cool your idea is. What you were seeing was either effective PR or dumb luck, neither of which can be duplicated trivially.
(b) One friggin week advantage is nothing. Usually the first player in a space takes it in the shins. It's so exceedingly rare for a first mover to win that calling it an advantage seems to ignore market realities.
Keep that in mind please. In spite of whatever the buzz is today, except for the top 10 sites or so the majority of websites have not been visited yet by the majority of the people on the planet.
There definitely is room for more than one in almost every space except for social networks that are 'feature comparable', sooner or later one will gain the momentum and crowd the other one out.
As a startup, don't assume that all your customers just read the great PR on your competitor. Most of them probably don't know that they want random chat (or live power monitoring)
Maybe I didn't give enough details in my original post. This was a little hack that I thought would be cool, and would help me learn how to write comet-based apps (which it did). When Omegle came out, was a little annoyed but since our project was a few days of work, I put the code away and focused on my main project. I didn't even hear of omegle again after then until a few weeks after that.
But still, my current project is chasing a first mover with a few months' head start and it's nice to get reaffirmation that we don't need to be first movers to get ahead.
P.S. If you're interested, here are slides from a presentation we gave in our local startup interaction session: http://www.slideshare.net/guest3cff7f/connr
I can’t help but read that as giving up at the first sign of trouble. Sure, competition sucks, but if you had just a single advantage you could have used the Omegle buzz to your advantage and effectively ride their coattail, what many tablets are presently trying to do with the buzz surrounding the iPad.
While I will gladly compete when I feel that there is a potential for becoming better than the competitor (like I'm doing right now with my current startup), I can't bring myself to do something that offers nothing new and attempt to "out-market" the competition.
Look at fads in music for confirmation of this. Lady Gaga got big last year.. and now we have Ke$ha basically playing a similar card. Boy bands? Crap, when they come out, you end up with 101 boy band clones within a couple of years.
Get in on the fad, but execute in a way that makes you distinctive.
Even if you play ChatRoulette legitimately, the number of people who will actually talk back to you is ridiculously low. You can get into typed conversations with people and they won't open their mouths a bit. People also seem OK with just staring at each other. It's like an awkward subway ride.
Using nothing but the tinychat API to do it.
Just figure out a way to differentiate yourself.
1. Better layout, make it a truly glorious experience...a few extra KBs to load an interesting background is nothing when you are streaming gigs of data.
2. Focus on the U.S. factor. That guy is trying to have the best of both worlds, but Germany is really not that close. So focus your service on U.S. and Canada and offer faster speeds.
3. Offer easy ways to share screen caps. I dunno something like a report where you show screen cap of person #1 and screen cap of person #2 + the actual text. Host it on your own server, so that people(reddit/digg) can just link to the chats in question.
Seriously. Chatroulette may be a great idea, but when 20% of the users are trying to shock the rest of them (or are "legitimately" perving out on camera), it destroys the return visitor rate. I know plenty of people, including myself, that were initially interested in the site, but couldn't get past the gross factor.
ChatRoulette is not short of problems. Some people on reddit did a "study" where they found that some large percentage of "chats" were with masturbating men. Can you fix this? Probably. Add a check box saying 'show masturbating men' (I'm gonna say this should default to 'no'. Then when you end a conversation, allow a user to specific that they ended it because there was a masturbating man at the other end.
As far as I'm concerned, ChatRoulette is unusable until this is solved.
Obviously not. You seem to have an issue with self-validation. The most salient fact about chatroullette is that it is a piece of garbage. Find out why that is, then fix it, and put out your own service.
Quick idea: Have "categories", like "weight lifting" or "chess playing" or "NASCAR fans", etc, etc. And then have timed quizzes to prove that people actually fit the category. Then they can talk to similar enthusiasts.
My biggest concern is that I thought the site would be so cool that traffic would grow exponentially from organic word of mouth. Now that there is a Chatroulette, I'm afraid it loses its wow factor.
In fact, I can still think of some features that would lower the penis count and increase the usefulness/fun of the site.
edit: Is this query too off-topic? Should I start another thread? Seemed like a good place to ask.