News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ghost in the Shell remains our most challenging film abou... by viraptor on Monday February 29, 2016 @09:01PM (#11200315)
GitS pushed ideas on many fronts in every episode, but Minority Report felt to me really shallow. I mean, how deep does the precog go? Why aren't they used in worldwide politics? If only 3 are used for crime prevention, what happened to the other ones? Why is it murder prevention specifically? How did the local police start with the program rather than a federal agency - mutating people is not something that would be a quiet local development.

It's been some time since I've seen MR, so maybe I'm missing details, but it seemed to show a big idea and then concentrate on tiny group only / action sequences. Kind of the reverse of GitS showing the actions of tiny group, but never losing the context of the big idea.

Re:Ghost in the Shell remains our most challenging film abou... by newman314 on Monday February 29, 2016 @09:09PM (#11200351)
Keep in mind, it's a movie vs. a tv series so there's only so much time to explore different concepts. Plus I would not focus on the fact that it's just the 3 people but rather the notion of pre-crime itself.

The current TV version of Minority Report unfortunately does not seem to have tackled these issues much and is more like a near future police drama instead. Bummer