Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by SEJeff on Monday February 29, 2016 @05:59PM
(#11199407)
I'd actually love to see this one make it to the supreme court, where I have pretty much no doubt, they would reach the exact same conclusion.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by joezydeco on Monday February 29, 2016 @06:05PM
(#11199437)
Or, the SCOTUS (currently down to 8 Justices) would deadlock and the ruling would fall back to the lesser court's decision in favor of the government. Forever.
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by dragonwriter on Monday February 29, 2016 @06:44PM
(#11199698)
> Or, the SCOTUS (currently down to 8 Justices) would deadlock and the ruling would fall back to the lesser court's decision in favor of the government. Forever.
No, a Supreme Court deadlock has essentially the same effect as if the case had not been appealed to the Supreme Court; the Court of Appeals decision stands, but no binding precedent (other than the local precedent already created by the Court of Appeals decision) is created. So, its not "forever", even in the limited sense that a Supreme Court decision is "forever".
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by SEJeff on Monday February 29, 2016 @07:02PM
(#11199796)
^ This is the correct answer
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by Rylinks on Monday February 29, 2016 @06:08PM
(#11199463)
A tie in SCOTUS does not create binding precedent. Other circuit courts would be free to disagree, and a later SCOTUS could rule against the government.
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by HelloMcFly on Monday February 29, 2016 @07:23PM
(#11199893)
I have a most difficult time believing SCOTUS would deadlock on this issue as it should scratch the "personal property, limited government, narrow interpretation" itch of the conservative justices and the civil rights itch of the liberal justices.
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by kevin_thibedeau on Monday February 29, 2016 @09:18PM
(#11200379)
Those same conservative justices who have no problem with eminent domain being used to enrich private entities.
Re:Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force App...
by mkempe on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:02AM
(#11200887)
Kelo:
- Dissent: O'Connor, joined by Rehnquist, Scalia, Thomas
- Dissent: Thomas