Re:Most software already has a “golden key” backdoor: the sy...
by alextgordon on Sunday February 28, 2016 @01:24PM
(#11191754)
Isn't that discredited by Apple's "goto fail" bug? A critical function was mistakenly circumvented in an extremely transparent way, and yet the source code sat on their website for a long time without anybody noticing. Nobody even ran coverity on it.
Re:Most software already has a “golden key” backdoor: the sy...
by fleshweasel on Sunday February 28, 2016 @04:35PM
(#11192488)
goto fail was in OpenSSL which many organizations use, but your point still stands.
Re:Most software already has a “golden key” backdoor: the sy...
by stouset on Sunday February 28, 2016 @05:42PM
(#11192741)
No, this was a bug in SecureTransport, Apple's custom TLS implementation.
Re:Most software already has a “golden key” backdoor: the sy...
by fleshweasel on Sunday February 28, 2016 @08:37PM
(#11193231)
Oops. You're right. Sorry.
In a word: no. With open source code, you could use software authored by the NSA, like SELinux, or you could even hire a manifestly untrustworthy party like Hacking Team to author some code and still be able to trust the code.
In Apple's case, there is a fairly good reason to trust Apple because it would be a hell of a kabuki theatre production to have the FBI and Apple battle in a Supreme Court case while colluding in secret. But would you trust a defense contractor? A telco? Limit or ideally eliminate the need for trust. Fortunately it is possible to reduce the need for trust below having to trust groups or individuals.