News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by adventured on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:17AM (#11190647)
Except for the fact that land taxes are regressive and extraordinarily evil toward the bottom ~50%, the people that have by far the most difficulty affording their property taxes each year.

Ted Turner isn't having a problem paying his property taxes. The rich will never have a problem paying their property taxes. It's the poorest that struggle with it. Fully distributed land value taxes discourage property ownership by the non-wealthy, which will increase wealth inequality.

If you then plan to create exclusion lines based on wealth or income, that drop people out of having to pay property taxes - well then you're just going to create a lot of other problems in which you're punishing people just above that line that can hardly afford the tax either.

If you want to use a very finely graduated property taxation approach, good luck fairly managing it across a nation as large and diverse as the US in terms of incomes / land values / standards of living / et al.

If you make a person pay $3,000-$4,000 annually on their homeowners taxes per year, with said person having a median income in a house valued at the median, then what you'll accomplish is every ten years you're guaranteed to have completely wiped out all value gain created by that person owning their home and paying down their mortgage.

Property taxes are just about the most regressive taxation device ever implemented. The only thing worse is the basic income, in which the rich are given a welfare hand-out.

Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by Lazare on Sunday February 28, 2016 @07:36AM (#11190771)
We're talking about a land value tax, not a property tax. They're quite different, and if you're curious about the logic behind them then by all means read the original article, or the Wikipedia article on Georgism, both of which go into some detail. Also, note that a land value tax would be progressive, not regressive.

Also, while obviously they could be wrong, if Krugman and Stiglitz think it's a good idea, and Marx was afraid it would help the proletariat out so much that it would delay the revolution, it's probably a sign that it's not as obviously "extraordinarily evil toward the bottom ~50%" as you seem to imagine.

Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by nkurz on Sunday February 28, 2016 @07:23PM (#11193058)
I think it's likely that 'adventured' understands the difference, and chose Turner as the example because he owns 2,000,000 acres (~100000 hectares) of mostly unimproved ranch land: http://www.tedturner.com/turner-ranches/

This makes him the second largest landowner in North America, after John Malone.

Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by pjc50 on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:34AM (#11190677)
completely wiped out all value gain created by that person owning their home

Think about this for a second: where does this value come from? Most capital assets depreciate. We're too used to property as an eternally appreciating asset.

Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by XorNot on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:59AM (#11190714)
Because land is a finite resource compared to all other sources of capital. There is no more of it to be had.
Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by kimdouglasmason on Sunday February 28, 2016 @11:09AM (#11191217)
There are vast amounts of land, even within American cities, that is very cheap. The amount of usable land for urban purposes might as well be infinite.

Land is only expensive in a few select locations that have specific infrastructure and industries. It is the infrastructure and industries that provide the value; even the most picturesque accessible fertile land is quite cheap if it's not in a city.

Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age i... by mcguire on Sunday February 28, 2016 @05:09PM (#11192601)
Land in close proximity to a few select locations is a finite resource. (The point of Manhattan, say, is that it's compact.)