Re:What My PhD Was Like
by Rainymood on Sunday February 28, 2016 @03:44AM
(#11190354)
Are PhDs expensive, do you get paid? In Europe you are actually a full time worker for the university and get paid a living wage (bit lower than industry but it ramps up I guess).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by emeryberger on Sunday February 28, 2016 @10:56AM
(#11191176)
In Computer Science, PhD students at any reasonable institution are invariably funded (stipend + tuition & some fees). Most who are in non-theoretical fields get research assistantships, which pay for them to do their PhD without any teaching responsibilities. The pay is in no way comparable to industrial salaries (OK, it's comparable; it's WAY less). The University of Massachusetts Amherst, where I am a faculty member, pays our PhD students more than $2,500 per month, plus benefits. This is a pretty competitive figure. However, many PhD students do summer research internships at places like Microsoft Research, IBM Research, Facebook, and Google, and these pay pretty handsomely.
Furthermore the student stipend may go further because many needs at a big university may subsidized. These include student residences, gyms, health care, etc. To maintain the same lifestyle after leaving the ubiversity was more expensive.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by emeryberger on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:13PM
(#11192850)
I should have clarified: the above is for US institutions (and I believe Canada). I do not know how things are in other countries.
This is not true in the UK. You are paid a tax free stipend (currently ~£14k) and not considered a full worker - you certainly don't have the rights that full time staff have.
There is no salary progression, bonus or pension and your funding cuts off at 3/3.5/4 years. After that, you aren't eligible for any govt. benefits as you are a full time student.
In some parts of the UK £14k can go a long way, but UK PhD students definitely aren't equal to full time staff as it stands.
The pay can be higher with industry partnerships (£30k tax free!!) but this is the more usual research council level.
You might get a tax free stipend... :) Depends on whether you get a scholarship! (I have a PhD student of mine who has a "fees only" scholarship - she is employed doing other things at the university but that's separate from the PhD.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by _Wintermute on Sunday February 28, 2016 @08:18AM
(#11190844)
Thankfully there has been a shift recently by the funding bodies to increase the stipend beyond the required minimum. Many in biomedical programmes are offering £18-20k a year.
Not true for Portugal too. For my PhD I got a scholarship of 980€/month (too much below standard market rates for software engineers around here) and was not considered full time worker, so I had no benefits, no insurance, nada, zip.
Although I consider it to be one of the best times that I had, in professional terms I didn't got much from it unfortunately..
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by theparanoid on Sunday February 28, 2016 @03:45AM
(#11190360)
They pay a subsistence living.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by frozenport on Sunday February 28, 2016 @05:02AM
(#11190532)
$21k USD in the USA, I've often been envious of my European colleagues!