Re:What My PhD Was Like
by munin on Saturday February 27, 2016 @11:59PM
(#11189937)
the strict timeline can be a lie. yeah, on paper, you have a 3 year plan, but it fails most of the time so students wind up taking unpaid years to finish.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I did my PhD in The Netherlands. In my field (computational linguistics), the majority of people finished within the allotted four years. The working conditions are good: PhDs are generally employed as regular employees with vacation money and 13th month. The teaching duties were very light (typically TAing and later teaching one 7-week course), giving you a lot of time to focus on research.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by programLyrique on Sunday February 28, 2016 @05:13AM
(#11190555)
Same in France: all the PhD students in computer science I know have finished in 3 years, or 3 years and 6 months (you can request a 6 month extension). You can't carry on after that duration because you have to be funded and be full-time (so no side job).
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by emeryberger on Sunday February 28, 2016 @10:48AM
(#11191152)
FWIW, these (IMHO absurdly) short PhD programs basically mean you need to do a postdoc for your CV to even be competitive with US CS PhDs -- assuming you want to do research in a top institution or research lab. So it's far from an obvious optimization.
That was not my experience. I did a PhD in quantum physics in the UK (Imperial College) in 3 years + 6 month extension. I collaborated with Oxford University and I was able to publish in Nature Physics, PRL, etc ... (in other words, the top journals in the field). I was offered post-doc positions but eventually went to industry.
I really enjoyed my PhD as a time to learn and think about deep and difficult questions. Regarding employment, I think it shows that you can commit to a problem. It shows perseverance and drive. And those are good skill to have at any technical job.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by emeryberger on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:12PM
(#11192841)
My comments should be interpreted as applying to PhD studies in Computer Science.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by JupiterMoon on Sunday February 28, 2016 @04:58PM
(#11192567)
The view from Europe is that since students in US PhD programs spend their first two years doing courses they come out with similar actual research experience.
Re:What My PhD Was Like
by emeryberger on Sunday February 28, 2016 @06:10PM
(#11192835)
The view is wrong. In computer science -- at least at top programs -- students begin research immediately.
In my area, no-one has failed their 3 year plan yet, maybe up to 4 years taken - our area has very little Australian citizens so the incentives are large.
(there's an obvious Soviet joke here about 3 year plans)