Re:52-hertz whale
by userbinator on Saturday February 27, 2016 @08:03PM
(#11189260)
I wonder if it's really a whale, or some sort of man-made source (possibly a classified military technology) that coincidentally happens to be particularly whale-like?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I thought of that, but if I were making some secret military sound I would try very hard to blend in exactly like other whales, not do something unique and identifiable.
Re:52-hertz whale
by marcosdumay on Saturday February 27, 2016 @09:35PM
(#11189532)
But this is 52Hz, just around the 50Hz that a big part of the world uses as electrical standard. Some hidden generator somewhere could cause it.
I guess the hardest part to explain (in an artificial source) is how it migrates all the time, not the pitch.
Unlikely that broken electricity generator would be as loud as a whale, and survive 30years without repair.
Also, would someone choose to generate AC in a marine application?
Thw wikipedia article mentions that the US Navy partially declassified thoe orginal recordings after the Cold War, and made the array availble to researchers.
If there was a military tech involved (with the source), I highly doubt they would have declassified that or as a conspiracy theory, it is misdirection...
Re:52-hertz whale
by audiosampling on Sunday February 28, 2016 @03:00PM
(#11192112)
Makes sense. Trying to mask an acoustic signature around 50-60Hz, by using a sound that ressembles to a whale.