News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by CamperBob2 on Saturday February 27, 2016 @05:19AM (#11186700)
Counterpoint: if a third party can't get its act together for the clusterfuck of a Presidential election we're about to experience, it may not be entirely the system's fault.
Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by mtgx on Saturday February 27, 2016 @07:37AM (#11186932)
You "can't get your act together" as a third party in a First Past the Post system. The winning strategy is always to vote for the 2 biggest parties. And the media not only strongly favors the two parties and cuts everyone else out from the discussion, but they also cut out any "grassroots" activist that is anti-establishment (unless you're already a media celebrity like Trump, which ends up getting them higher ratings).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo&app=desktop

43% of Americans are Independents, and only 29% D and 23% R. And yet most of them still end up voting D or R - do you think that just happens because they end up liking the D or R, or because it's a systemic problem that always forces them to vote for the "lesser evil"?

If you don't think this is not just a problem, but a catastrophic one for US democracy, then the media has brainwashed Americans more than I thought.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig

Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday February 27, 2016 @09:12AM (#11187112)
I agree with your tone, but sadly even in parliamentary systems with third and fourth parties like the UK and Canada, there is a strong bipolar two-party emphasis. And even worse the two parties that do capture power (in Canada the Liberals and Conservatives and in the UK Labour and the Conservatives) have themselves tended towards a rather homogeneous ideological mean, easily poaching policy from each other and rarely altering things that the previous party's gov't had enacted. A fairly standard neo-liberal consensus has settled over all western democracies that even the brutal crisis of 2008 couldn't shake, despite some rather horrible dysfunctions -- stagnant economic growth, growing wealth inequality, endemic poverty that doesn't go away, and a staggering slow moving long term environmental crisis that is going to make our children loathe us. Only in the periphery, in places like Greece, etc. have there been significant alterations to the political consensus, and that was quickly and efficiently snuffed out by the actions of the more "sensible" European mainstream...

In the end -- there's only one way of doing political-economy right now within the confines of western capitalist democracy. All the capital-P Politics is theatre around the margins.

Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by ZanyProgrammer on Saturday February 27, 2016 @10:47AM (#11187373)
What is really needed is genuine proportional representation, not FPTP (like in Britain). Another problem is that with three parties, voting for the third may siphon off votes from its nearest analogue (i.e. the NDP and Liberals in Canada under Harper).
Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by jsjohnst on Saturday February 27, 2016 @09:21AM (#11187139)
I don't disagree with them on face, but do you have a source for those percentages?
Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by 7952 on Saturday February 27, 2016 @06:45AM (#11186846)
People assumes that the underlying structure of a political party is an effective mechanism for getting power simply because a couple of parties have a lot of power. But at the grass roots political parties are just very pretentious social clubs. Trying to compete on that level seems prone to failure.

It is much easier to try and influence the direction of one of the incumbent parties by taking over the leadership (Trump) or just purchasing influence. So you get parties that are completely detached from the underlying ethos that their members naively assume exists. But actually a large party has no more ethos than a golf club or a frat house.

Re:AT&T sues Louisville to stop Google Fiber from using its ... by douche on Saturday February 27, 2016 @08:12AM (#11186992)
Teddy Roosevelt couldn't make a third party work, and that was in a pretty lack-luster field.