Re:Content ID and the Rise of the Machines
by JoshTriplett on Friday February 26, 2016 @09:25PM
(#11185765)
This is exactly the fundamental problem with YouTube's ContentID system as compared to the DMCA system (and I never thought I'd be observing a case where the DMCA is an improvement). On sites relying on the DMCA notice and counter-notice mechanism, you can file a counter-notice and your content will go back up. The site can rely on that, and the party making a claim over your content has to go after you rather than the site.
With that system, if you're confident something is public domain, or fair use, or any number of other reasons why a claim is invalid, you can just say "put it back up". There's no option for the claimant to "reject" your "dispute".
https://archive.org/details/his_girl_friday
As soon as it was finished uploading, I was notified that a copyright owner (Sony Pictures, which I guess owns the remnants of the defunct studio that produced His Girl Friday) had issued a takedown notice. Amusingly, a minute later, I received the usual "Congratulations, your video is now on YouTube!" email that you get when successfully publishing a video.
After getting a takedown notice, you have the option to dispute it, which I did, providing evidence that His Girl Friday is indeed in the public domain. A short time later, I got a note saying that my dispute was rejected, and that I could choose to fight it -- but that the decision would be up to the rights holder (Sony). However, if the rights owner chose again to deny me, my YouTube account would be penalized and I could possibly lose uploading capabilities.
I didn't really care enough to fight it (though I've kept the screenshots and emails to document the process)...anyone else get to this stage and succeed (or fail)?