Re:Doing Mathematics Differently
by eli_gottlieb on Saturday February 27, 2016 @12:49PM
(#11187794)
Nah, Omega is just defined as a number which contains countably infinite bits of algorithmic information. Since algorithmic information is equivalent to thermodynamic information (and likewise relates to quantum information if you head in that direction...), the whole "you can't calculate Omega" thing is really just a way of saying, "You can't have an infinite-precision physical measurement encoded into a finite physical system."
Chaitin makes far too much metaphysics of his work.
Re:Doing Mathematics Differently
by Houshalter on Saturday February 27, 2016 @02:37PM
(#11188120)
I don't really understand the insight with Chaitin's number. It's unknowable, but so are a lot of things. The halting problem already says that there are programs which we can't know if they will halt or not. And before that, Godel showed there are simple logical sentences which are true and unprovable.
So we are left with the weird conclusion:
1. It has the value it has for no reason.
2. It has the value it has for a reason that is impossible to formulate.