News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by acveilleux on Thursday February 25, 2016 @09:21PM (#11179449)
When the resource being abused by sci-hub (a university's ezproxy server, via a hacked or shared user account) is shut down by publisher locking out a whole university because an account downloaded 10000 papers over a week-end, there is a real loss. It is not a theoretical moral quandary.

Obviously, the loss is kind of abstract for the publisher but it isn't for the small college that spends half or more of its annual acquisition budget on journal subscriptions and is then locked out of what it spent tens or hundreds of thousands on (depending strictly on which publisher locked them out until they can demonstrate that abuse as been shut down.)

Sure, if you're Hardvard or Stanford library, you can play hardball with the publisher and get your access restored immediately but if you're a small institution, someone's week in the library just got ruined to satisfy the platform owner that abuse has been shut down... For now. It really hurts the small institutions who can least afford it.

Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by jononor on Friday February 26, 2016 @05:41AM (#11180761)
Why ruined? Can't they just use sci-hub to do their research? ;)
Re:Sci-Hub as necessary, effective civil disobedience by acveilleux on Friday February 26, 2016 @01:58PM (#11183245)
That doesn't help the poor librarian that will now spend 3 days going back and forth with the platform while the front desk has to explain to the various users why they cannot get their articles from Journals for which the library already has a subscription.