News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by pg on Thursday February 11, 2010 @11:09AM (#1117899)
I think the reason so many VCs think the VC business needs to shrink is not that there' some limit on the number of startups, but because of a historical accident that caused the VC business to bloat suddenly. The bubble of the late 90s caused a great increase in the number of VC firms, and many of the new arrivals were incompetent. When VCs say the VC business is going to shrink, it's largely a tactful way of saying that those firms are going to get GCed.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @11:32AM (#1117949)
Actually, I pretty strongly think that there is a limit on the number of startups, if by "startup" you mean "small company in which people create wealth largely through computer programming".

According to the BLS, there are 1.3 million "software engineers" and programmers in the United States (cite: http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos303.htm). This number will go up over the next fifty years, but not by that much; projected growth is 2% annually. One could see this number increasing more rapidly if programmers are in so much demand that their salaries (either in the form of cash or startup equity) go up very fast, but we don't see that happening; programmers nowadays don't get paid that much more, in either dollars or equity, than programmers five or ten years ago.

Now, how many of these programmers have the skills needed to start a successful company? Let's be optimistic and say 10%, which is probably above your estimate ("The top 5% of programmers probably write 99% of the good software", cite: http://www.paulgraham.com/wealth.html).

Now, out of those, how many have the personality and determination needed to start a successful company? In the overall population this number is probably less than 5%, but the traits needed to become a good programmer (high energy, determination, ability to think well) probably correlate significantly with the traits needed to start a successful company, so I'll be optimistic again and say 25%.

Now, what's the viable window for programmers to start companies? At a guess, I'd say probably around age 22-37, so 15 years. I'm going to be optimistic again and assume that all working programmers are within this age range.

Now, how many founder-class programmers do you need to start a successful company? This number could probably range from one to five, but I'm going to be optimistic again and say one.

So, dividing it out, the number of successful startups every year is bounded above by 1,300,000 * 0.1 * 0.25 / 15 = ~2,200, and this is almost certainly an overestimate.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by pg on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:04PM (#1118233)
The number of programmers is pretty elastic. People can and will learn to program if it starts to seem like that's a valuable skill. E.g. there is a founder in this current YC cycle who came to the US to go to business school, but then realized that if he wanted to start a startup he'd be better off spending the time learning to hack instead.

I'd say the upper bound on the number of startups is the number of people who are determined and smart enough. That's probably between 1 in 100 and 1 in 1000.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by gaius on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:35PM (#1118344)
People can and will learn to program if it starts to seem like that's a valuable skill.

But they won't tho', not really. In the dotcom boom there were plenty of such people who learnt HTML and were (well) paid for it for a couple of years. But they didn't or couldn't make the jump to possessing a skillset that kept them in the industry after the meltdown. The guys with C++ or Sybase or whatever under their belts, just kept right on truckin'.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by DaniFong on Thursday February 11, 2010 @07:41PM (#1119261)
All of the scientists I know know how to hack. A philosophy grad student I know built a neat little philosophy bot. http://webscript.princeton.edu/~amendelo/skeptic/

Hacking is starting to be a new literacy. What's more, the most important part of startups isn't really programming, which is getting easier and easier, but understanding customer's problems. Here a wide range of backgrounds are useful.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:22PM (#1118296)
"People can and will learn to program if it starts to seem like that's a valuable skill."

That's basically just a restatement of what I said (more people will learn to program if there are greater rewards for doing so). The thing is, there aren't greater rewards for doing so. Startups aren't any more profitable now than they were ten years ago, and programmers at big companies don't make more now than they did ten years ago (inflation-adjusted).

"I'd say the upper bound on the number of startups is the number of people who are determined and smart enough. That's probably between 1 in 100 and 1 in 1000."

Few could argue that, say, investment bankers are quite smart and extremely determined (and very good at sales besides), but there's extremely little overlap between investment bankers and technical startup founders, and that doesn't look like it's going to change. Same for corporate law, management consulting, etc. Plenty of i-bankers and consultants and corporate lawyers go into other fields, including non-technical startup positions (eg. Jessica Livingston). Indeed, one of the primary reasons people go into these industries is for the exit opportunities. But very few seem to learn how to code.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:41PM (#1118366)
Maybe I should clarify what I mean by "upper bound". "Upper bound" means "how high could the number go if parameters X, Y, and Z are allowed to vary", but neither of us specified what X, Y, and Z were. The hypotheticals I was considering were "suppose the startup community all acted in unison towards increasing the number of startups". For instance, if the startup community exerted enough collective pressure, we could plausibly get Sarbanes-Oxley loosened, or force VCs to become more technically competent, or make it easier for founders to immigrate. But we can't just decide to increase how profitable it is to learn to program or start a startup; these things are driven by consumer demand.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by robryan on Thursday February 11, 2010 @05:50PM (#1118992)
I think this number also depends on the bound on markets that can be monetized, when you see the scale that some startups need to achieve to become profitable their is only really room for a finite number of successful startups in any one market space.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by huherto on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:20PM (#1118087)
I followed your calculations, but I am not sure what point are you trying to make. Are you saying that the upper limit of start ups is 2200 and it is limited by the number of highly capable programmers. What about the Market? Is there enough space in the market for 2200 new start ups?
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by pg on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:05PM (#1118240)
That's equivalent to asking, are people's desires limited? The answer appears to be no, in the short term.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by usaar333 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @06:37PM (#1119120)
It is more asking:

A) Do people have the time/money to use X products? and B) Are there X people who want to use a given product (at a given price/time point)?

I have no doubt that there is a limit on the number of successful startups due to A and B.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:37PM (#1118151)
My point is, even though there are an infinite number of applications to write, there aren't an infinite number of people to write them.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by gridspy on Thursday February 11, 2010 @09:35PM (#1119558)
One interesting thing is that a very good programmer might look at those numbers and go "how am I going to beat 1,300,000 people to make the next facebook" whereas it is closer to "how am I going to join the 2,200 startups that make it big?"
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by FreeRadical on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:05PM (#1118052)
You've excluded successful startups founded by non programmers.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:36PM (#1118144)
I explicitly defined "startup" to mean companies that need programming skill (as this seems to be the way the word is used nowadays), and there are very few of those that have zero programmers as founders.
[deleted]
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by apsec112 on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:29PM (#1118327)
To get "per year" instead of "per however long a programmer remains in the industry". Suppose there are X programmers in the US who could plausibly start a startup. All X people can't start companies when they're 22, and again when they're 23, and again when they're 24, etc. (the vast majority of founders only ever start one company). So, if you assume that 1/15th of the programming population starts when they're 22, 1/15th starts when they're 23, etc., the total fraction of people who start in any given year is 1/15 * 1/15 + 1/15 * 1/15 + 1/15 * 1/15 + ... = 15 * (1/15 * 1/15) = 1/15th.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by JesseAldridge on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:40PM (#1118361)
Yeah, I got that after a bit. Heh, it seems you replied at the exact moment I deleted my post.

For the record, the question was, "Why did you divide by 15?"

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by btilly on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:24PM (#1118099)
You are right. However the airline industry is a demonstration that persistent oversupply can sometimes exist indefinitely.

Though admittedly that example is being propped up by the Chapter 11 bankruptcy laws that repeatedly lets companies on the verge of dying get rescued instead. (I'd love to see chapter 11 bankruptcy go away.)

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by coliveira on Thursday February 11, 2010 @12:44PM (#1118168)
If chapter 11 bankruptcy goes away it will be bad only for employees. Because investors are already wiped out by bankruptcy and upper management can always negotiate sweet deals for when/if it happens.
Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by btilly on Thursday February 11, 2010 @01:38PM (#1118357)
I'm guessing that you're not very familiar with the history of the airline industry.

The problem is that there are too many competitors, someone fails, go into chapter 11, with the competitive advantages they get from chapter 11 they become healthy, there remain too many competitors and another one fails. At this point most of the major airlines have been in and out of chapter 11 multiple times, and the airline industry still has structural problems of too many airlines. But with every round life has gotten worse for the employees. To such an extent that pilot has gone from a good job to a piece of crap job that people only stay in because they have already sunk the cost of their training and love to fly.

If chapter 11 wasn't there then this cycle would never have caught on. But the artificial boost for companies that are ready to go away is artificially distorting the market to everyone's disadvantage. And it has stayed distorted for a period of decades.

Re:Every time an engineer joins Google, a startup dies by marshallp on Thursday February 11, 2010 @09:13PM (#1119516)
I disagree, I think it's simply that the VC's are incompetent. They don't use data to make their judgements, relying instead on gut feelings. They don't have a systematic procedure/checklist to make decisions, or even a systematic way for entrepreneurs to to see them. They don't even like to hire analysts as is common in the rest of banking. It's simply not a 'prefessional' industry yet.

It's not the fault of individuals in the vc (they have to run fast just to keep up), just the industry hasn't had enough academics/software telling them to how to more reliably run their business.