Here's a fun article on cooking beef: Bob del Grosso, from the Culinary Institute, losing his shit over how Mark Bittman writes up his technique for the NYTimes:
http://ahungerartist.bobdelgrosso.com/2010/01/minimalist-of-...
Tip: Most olive oils have relatively lower smoke points, especially if you're using virgin. So, if you want to prevent most of the smoke, try canola oil. The OO isn't doing much for flavor, especially if it's burning. Also, a pat of butter at the end is essential.
The diff:
1. crack peppercorns spread across a baking sheet. Lay steak upon them. Compress. I use a heavy (cold) skillet. Flip steak. Repeat.
2. Heat oil just beneath the smoke point in pan, otherwise cook steak as described.
3. Serve with any citrus-based steaksauce. (A1 if you have to, but I prefer to make my own OJ based sauce)
The peppercorn crust is quite good.
Beautiful with the peppered crust.
Being able to make a good pan-sauce is a skill that provides one of the best returns on the time investment for a home cook (second only to making your own stocks and glaces.)
In the frenzy of mixing things and moving ingredients around you tend to forget the pan is still at ~500F.
This tip has been brought to you by the scar on my left palm.
The steak will be tender and juicy, since searing it at such a hot temperature locks in most of the juices, similar to the way a wound is cauterized.
I only recommend you do this if you have a VERY well ventilated kitchen, as the amount of smoke generated will surely set off any smoke alarms in your house otherwise.
Sidenote: Why is it that a lot of modern kitchens don't have properly ventilated hoods that actually vent outside? It seems ridiculous that most of the hoods over stoves nowadays just recirculate the air back inside. When I want to cook, I want to cook, damn it!