News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by bdrool on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:16AM (#11173269)
Real Estate is the official state religion of California, and Prop 13 is our gospel. God willing, if we all just lock arms and make sure nothing new ever gets built, we can all enjoy the free money that comes from our artificially-limited housing supply, at least for those lucky enough to have gotten in early. (Everyone else can go pound sand.)

And the best part? The press will willingly write article after article snidely implying that it's all the fault of the young tech workers who have the audacity to move here in hopes of having a career. No one will ever mention that it's actually the fat bloated homeowners who are the cause of it all.

Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by crdoconnor on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:03AM (#11173686)
Prop 13 wasn't driven by homeowners, it was driven by property developers. Homeowners are just along for the ride.

Untaxing land - as prop 13 did - is essentially just the privatization of the right to collect tax.

Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by ryandrake on Thursday February 25, 2016 @11:18AM (#11175397)
Prop 13 is a blatant wealth transfer from the young, who have to pay taxes based on today's prices, to the old, who got in long ago and pay their taxes based on yesterday's prices.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by crdoconnor on Thursday February 25, 2016 @01:25PM (#11176496)
It's more of a wealth transfer from poor to rich than it is young to old.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by mathattack on Thursday February 25, 2016 @07:31AM (#11173958)
Yes - rent seeking in both the economic and colloquial definition. :-)
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday February 25, 2016 @07:49AM (#11174032)
Well, TBH it is the tech workers driving demand-if you believe as I do that the increased supply of housing will greatly moderate prices, the flip side of that is that demand does exist, and the demand part of supply and demand works. The solution (build more, lots more) is obvious, but its not like accepting 200K/year FB/Apple/etc job doesn't have moral issues attached.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by mc32 on Thursday February 25, 2016 @11:11AM (#11175345)
It really does not have any moral issues attached to moving into a given community and paying rent or buying property so long as you're not engaging in illegal behavior like forced evictions, etc.

It's like saying the poor moving into an affluent or apartments built in an affluent area have moral considerations because riff raff have a tendency to drive down prices of the real estate of homeowners.

It cuts both ways and neither makes sense.

Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by totalrobe on Thursday February 25, 2016 @11:13AM (#11175358)
Wow, so accepting a high paying engineering job with a consumer tech company is now immoral?

It's not like they're building weapons like the majority of tech on the east coast.

Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by PhasmaFelis on Thursday February 25, 2016 @11:49AM (#11175673)
What baffles me is that rent increases get blamed on the tenant looking for a decent place to live, instead of on the landlord who actually increases the rent. If we're going to blame a human at all, why aren't we blaming the person who is directly making the change?
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday February 25, 2016 @12:07PM (#11175837)
Why wouldn't the landlord raise rent? There's not a lot of housing alternatives (the supply of housing) and if your average tenant makes 125K instead of 70K, why not gouge them?
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by PhasmaFelis on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:00PM (#11178545)
I don't understand why people think that "making as much money as possible is the most important thing in the world" is a convincing moral argument. You could, for example, have argued that wealthier tenants lead to rising property values, which means the landlord has to raise his rents just to break even on the property taxes. That would have been a coherent argument that absolves all individual blame. Why would you lead with "greed is good"?

(And, again, I'm not personally saying that either the tenant or the landlord is at fault. I just don't understand why, if I've just been driven out of my home and I'm looking for someone nearby to blame, I would choose to pin it on the new tenant instead of the landlord.)

Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 25, 2016 @12:10PM (#11175864)
Its a free market. There is no one to blame, any more than there is someone to blame for buying a gallon of orange juice. Supply, demand, prices fluctuate.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by PhasmaFelis on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:02PM (#11177770)
I don't necessarily believe that it's either the landlord's or the tenant's fault, but I also think don't like how often people dismiss human suffering with "it's a free market" and a shrug. Markets are meant to serve humans, not the other way around.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 25, 2016 @04:43PM (#11178064)
Free markets serve them efficiently. You control rent - that doesn't serve the landlord very well, nor the person who would have paid more rent. Just the slob squatting there.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by PhasmaFelis on Thursday February 25, 2016 @05:45PM (#11178450)
See, this is why unquestioning free-market worship bothers me. The claim is always that free markets provide the greatest good for the greatest number, but in your own hypothetical the person-with-less-money is automatically an undeserving "squatting slob" compared to the person-with-more-money.
Re:San Jose: A Place Where the Poor Once Thrived by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 25, 2016 @06:12PM (#11178609)
Oh come on. Just a word. "The eminent citizen"