Re:Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
by ikeboy on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:07PM
(#11171901)
I think the argument I summarized in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11171344 is reasonable. In a nutshell, they say that we should apply the third party doctrine as if we're in a world without third parties. So in the tor case, if they would need to manually transfer information, then the identity of both people would be known. The basic intuition is that technology shouldn't allow more hiding. (This is a simplification, read the sources to understand the point being made.)
Regarding buying random phone numbers, I'd say again, analogies are only useful to demonstrate the existence of an area of law in which something is legal or illegal, but not useful for designing in detail the laws governing digital/networked activities. There's not a sufficient parallel to make any decisions based on any analogy to a previous situation or technology; there's only enough parallel to prevent closing off the discussion of making privacy violations illegal by saying "it's not".