Re:Optimizing for Fan Noise
by wtallis on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @11:35PM
(#1116906)
OS X has what is probably the most aggressive set of software optimizations aimed at increasing battery life, and no GUI to configure it. The only options you have without delving into command line tools are to turn down screen brightness, disable wi-fi and bluetooth, turn off extra processor cores, and quit applications. Fortunately, the defaults work very well for any common real-world use.
Windows offers pretty good configuration options for power management, including setting maximum processor speed (as a percentage) while running on battery or on AC.
The author seems to be blurring the lines between fixed tasks like transcoding videos and interactive tasks like games. It's not at all obvious that transcoding with a single-threaded app saves any power over the duration of the job than with a multi-threaded implementation. Most laptop CPUs don't have the kind of power gating that are on the latest chips like the Core i7, so even if no instructions are issued to a core, it still draws some power.
With interactive tasks, the only way to save power is to do less, so that the CPU and other components can spend most of their time waiting for the user while in a low-power state. Predictive caching and speculative execution increase the responsiveness of a system on average, but at the cost of performing some tasks whose results won't be used. The only real take-away from this article is that apps that might be used on the go should provide a way to disable these techniques.
(It's important to note that games don't do a lot of this stuff, so there your only options are to turn down the eye candy and the frame rate. A good example of how to accomplish this is Torchlight's netbook mode.)
Windows offers pretty good configuration options for power management, including setting maximum processor speed (as a percentage) while running on battery or on AC.
The author seems to be blurring the lines between fixed tasks like transcoding videos and interactive tasks like games. It's not at all obvious that transcoding with a single-threaded app saves any power over the duration of the job than with a multi-threaded implementation. Most laptop CPUs don't have the kind of power gating that are on the latest chips like the Core i7, so even if no instructions are issued to a core, it still draws some power.
With interactive tasks, the only way to save power is to do less, so that the CPU and other components can spend most of their time waiting for the user while in a low-power state. Predictive caching and speculative execution increase the responsiveness of a system on average, but at the cost of performing some tasks whose results won't be used. The only real take-away from this article is that apps that might be used on the go should provide a way to disable these techniques.
(It's important to note that games don't do a lot of this stuff, so there your only options are to turn down the eye candy and the frame rate. A good example of how to accomplish this is Torchlight's netbook mode.)