Re:Ask HN: Review my web app - Modern Ballots
by wlievens on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @05:55PM
(#1116298)
Not to rain on your parade here, but a multi-party system isn't paradise either. I'm not saying the duopoly is better, but multi-party systems are plagued with immobility, compromise for the sake of compromise, and lack of differentiation. Any European cynic will repeat that for you.
Re:Ask HN: Review my web app - Modern Ballots
by ericd on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @10:18PM
(#1116787)
I didn't say that I wanted a 3+ party system, the biggest advantage would be that you wouldn't get a situation where voting for your favorite candidate screws over your close second favorite but much more likely to win candidate, as happened with Gore in 2000 when a percentage of his would-be supporters voted for Nader instead.
Re:Ask HN: Review my web app - Modern Ballots
by bradbeattie on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @06:40PM
(#1116416)
Similar things could be said when moving from despotism to a democracy. No system's perfect, but some are demonstratively better than others.
Re:Ask HN: Review my web app - Modern Ballots
by bradbeattie on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:24PM
(#1115905)
Note that while the ballots are ratings ballots, they're interpreted as preference orderings with ties. So a ballot for five candidates with 5/3/3/3/3 is the same as a ballot with 4/1/1/1/1.
to name a few.
Not to discourage you, though, I think it's great.
Education might be a good place to start, and that seems to be what you're dabbling with in writing this web app. I'd be very interested to hear your ideas regarding the other issues, though (and any other issues you think of).
I don't believe the current system is codified in the US constitution, though I could be wrong - a friend and I couldn't find anything specifically prescribing the choose one candidate ballot system of voting in the national constitution when we looked. The specific methods might be decided at the state level.