Re:Bill Gates Says Apple Should Unlock the iPhone
by acqq on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:22AM
(#11157889)
I don't think you are responding to my post? At least I can't see which part of my post you comment, that is, what I am missing.
The issue here is if All Writs is a good legal basis for the precedent of "change your product."
Re:Bill Gates Says Apple Should Unlock the iPhone
by rrego on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:42AM
(#11157950)
Ah. I'm conflating multiple threads. I was referring to this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11157666
I agree with you about All Writs, I don't see any precedent for "change your product". Thanks for pointing my mistake out.
The FBI wants Apple to create "malicious" code/update/software version that would allow for multiple decryption attempts among other things. Apple CAN comply with these requests, probably easily. However, by doing so they will destroy trust in Apple signed code and set a precedent.
It doesn't matter WHO has the key because Apple will be acting in proxy.