2) I am glad you have such great success with Paypal. But it isn't the truth for others, so being righteous and saying other people must be doing something wrong or illegal is just really out of touch.
3. False. The truth is simple, when product sells it has to be replaced so it is available for the next order. If demand is rising it has to be replaced in greater quantities to keep up. So yes, product is going out the door, but now there are reorder points to fulfill to maintain inventory and satisfy new orders, shipping bills which must be paid, employee wages, sales tax to governments, employment taxes, rent, insurance etc, all which must be paid well before the 180 days are up. So if money is being needlessly held for long periods, a business can easily be put in jeopardy. Most e-commerce companies don't run on huge margins, so they do not have 12 months reserves saved to work from, which is essentially what it takes if they get a 6 month hold put on their funds. Worse, if they are really growing it will take much more then 12 months of reserves, which was true for a number of the business I was working with. And no, bank loans (or even factoring) to replace/purchase product are not "easy", "fast" or "low cost" for a small business, even with proven sales traction and new orders coming in. Instead these loans are generally treated as moderately high to high risk.
My point about Paypal and their offering loans to the same people whom have had funds held, stands separately and on its own. It is a horrid business practice and while not illegal that I can imagine, it sure does seem immoral. Again, I do not know if they are still doing this today, but you can search google and find examples within the last year of it taking place.
I really do hope you continue to have success with Paypal and your business. I also hope Paypal stops their "held funds" behavior as it relates to small businesses and give people their funds timely. I do not think it is too much to ask, banks and other clearing houses do it everyday and still provide solid fraud protection for everyone involved. As for anyone who asks me, I will continue to steer them to any provider other than Paypal, until I see that Paypal has made a change in reality not just in media speak.
2) I have done tens of millions of dollars of transactions over PayPal. I also once had my account put on hold back near when I was first going into business.
2) You are not allowed to capture funds from someone using a credit card until you are imminently shipping the product to the customer. You say "had the product to ship", but then I'm going to have to ask: how did the company "almost go out of business"? If they already have the product ready to ship, then all we are talking about here is a delay in compensation. If the company needed a loan, PayPal is not a company whom you are allowed to get a loan from, and money collected from sales is a loan until you deliver the product. Your worst-case scenario here is that you should be able to get the loan you need on extremely great terms given if you can really show to someone that you have a ton of money that will be coming to you in 180 days (and the fact that these people could not obtain a reasonable loan really then undermines the entire premise that they had good documentation for PayPal's underwriting...).