News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by coldtea on Monday February 22, 2016 @07:30AM (#11150347)
>Taking pictures, listening to music, even calling someone, all require high attention interaction over an unfit touchscreen.

Are you kidding me? All of those functions are 10x easier to do on the "unfit touchscreen" that on what we had before that (tiny non-touch screens, LCDs, 80's style arrays of buttons, etc).

And when it comes to actually taking the picture, changing track or volume etc, smartphones even offer physical buttons on the sides.

Remember trying to get to the 10th track of the 4th folder in your "physical" CD mp3 player or minidisk? Setting anything more advanced than zoom level and picture mode on a typical 2002-2005 compact camera?

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by collyw on Monday February 22, 2016 @07:45AM (#11150415)
Cd's usually only held about 10 -15 tracks, so it was hardly a problem getting lost in folders. Obscure functions on cameras are more likely to be obscure because of menu layouts rather than a touchscreen (its still difficult to find some obscure settings buried in menus whether you have a touchscreen or buttons).
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by icebraining on Monday February 22, 2016 @09:26AM (#11150949)
In the latter years, portable CD players often supported CD-Rs with MP3 tracks, so you could have 100+ tracks on a single disc. Have fun pressing "next" until you find the track you need! :)
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by khedoros on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:38PM (#11153143)
> Remember trying to get to the 10th track of the 4th folder in your "physical" CD mp3 player or minidisk? Setting anything more advanced than zoom level and picture mode on a typical 2002-2005 compact camera?

I remember putting my music on MP3 players for the last 12 years, having non-MP3 CDs before that, and being able to perform basic operations on them blind and one-handed. I remember using my non-touch camera being much quicker to adjust than the app in my phone, especially when I'm adjusting the more advanced settings.

Touchscreens are optimized for flexibility and portability, and they're great at those. They're terrible at being fit for specific purposes.

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by coldtea on Monday February 22, 2016 @03:11PM (#11153890)
>* I remember putting my music on MP3 players for the last 12 years, having non-MP3 CDs before that, and being able to perform basic operations on them blind and one-handed. I remember using my non-touch camera being much quicker to adjust than the app in my phone, especially when I'm adjusting the more advanced settings.*

You remember through rose colored glasses then.

Try using that non-touch early 00's compact camera again (and no cheating with DSLRs with dedicated aperture and speed dials). As for the "blind and one-handed" operation with the non-mp3 CDs, did that include changing through 200+ albums and 2000+ tracks?

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by khedoros on Monday February 22, 2016 @06:20PM (#11155176)
> Try using that non-touch early 00's compact camera again

I don't have a touch camera at all. The one that I do have isn't a DSLR, but includes various dials. That's my point: dedicated controls will always be better. A camera that primarily relies on a direction pad and menus is only slightly better than using a touchscreen (but it is better).

> As for the "blind and one-handed" operation with the non-mp3 CDs, did that include changing through 200+ albums and 2000+ tracks?

For the CDs? Of course not. I'm not going to claim that a single CD could hold that many, whether or not they were in MP3 format. As for the MP3 player, I tend to set playback to a particular artist or setting the player to randomly play song from the whole library (by sight, of course), then throw it in my pocket. From that point, basic playback control doesn't require me to take it out of my pocket, while I'd have to at least take out my phone and wake up the screen to start doing the same thing.

I've got to assume that the way we tend to use our devices differs enough that something that feels like a huge improvement to me is a piddling detail in your use-case. On the other hand, some of the ways that I liked using my devices have disappeared, or at least been de-emphasized in more recent models, and that's what I'm frustrated with.

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by agumonkey on Monday February 22, 2016 @08:17AM (#11150559)
90% of the time I need direct blind access to simple functions. Now I have to carefully swipe, carefully otherwise the app goes into gallery mode, or the picture is taken, and since I was pushing on the screen, it's blurry and I need two hands to do so.

Side picture buttons are increasingly rare if not defunct, volume rockers are still here though.

A lot of things that could be done quickly is now fragile and subtle. A side effect of translating desktop UX to IRL handheld gadgets, by the promise that software will be smart enough to make it one button away.

psedit: as noted below, I indeed never realized the volume rocker was bound to snapshot. My rant is half void now u_u;

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by oxplot on Monday February 22, 2016 @08:43AM (#11150700)
This can all be "fixed" in software. In fact, on my HTC One M8 which is running Cyanogenmod, if I double press the power button at anytime, it switches to camera app and I can then take photos by pressing either volume buttons. I don't need to (or do) look at the screen let alone interact with it.
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by khedoros on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:58PM (#11153322)
How often do you take a picture without needing to set the focus, or at least watching the screen to see when the app has finished its autofocus? More generally, beyond changing the volume or initiating a voice query, how much can you really do without pulling the device out to use the screen? Lack of hardware buttons and tactile feedback can't be fixed in software.
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by oxplot on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:19PM (#11154767)
Even with a purpose built DSLR, you still have to frame your shot. I meant I don't need to look at the screen to make the phone ready to shoot. I believe the software can go a long way. It will never be as UX friendly as a camera, sure.
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by khedoros on Monday February 22, 2016 @06:38PM (#11155268)
I agree that there's room for UX improvement in the software, and as a software guy myself, it's the first place I'm inclined to look at as a source of improvement. It's just that not all the problems have a software fix, in my opinion.

Thank you for the double-tap tip, though. It works in Marshmallow too, apparently.

Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by agumonkey on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:08AM (#11158035)
To me the issue is the lack of context and pressure. Physical interfaces tapped into deep human perception. Sub millimeter movements, skin sensitivity, change of texture, response curve. None of that is taken in account in the desktop design world. At least before, software was designed for high throughput and underpowered machines (I often find AS400 UX as ugly as efficient, and in reality nobody cares about software being pretty). Now you get Material Design. 80% eye candy. Whenever I have to use KitKat I feel so relieved because it has centered, static, squary input menus. I don't have to avoid overlapping free floating (+). Every new market causes a regression, until it learns lessons from the past. The learning phase is still going indeed.
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by TheCoreh on Monday February 22, 2016 @08:43AM (#11150698)
The volume rocker is usually a picture button, no?
Re:“Smartphone” is the wrong name by robotresearcher on Monday February 22, 2016 @03:08PM (#11153870)
> All of those functions are 10x easier to do on the "unfit touchscreen" that on what we had before that...

The old Blackberry devices were UI marvels. The physical scroll wheel was great.