You woud be surprised by how bad K-Mart, which merged with Sears, is at keeping things you need in stock. If you want to buy something commonplace, like a particular model of Crock Pot or a particular Corelle dish, odds are about10% that the nearest K-Mart has it vs about 90% that Wal Mart has it. Clearly there is still a big difference enabled by Wal Mart's IT and business processes. Especially since once the odds of wasting time and a car trip go up just a bit the backstop is to order the thing from Amazon.
I'm not suggesting that it's advisable to run a Fortune 50 company by gut instinct.
I am suggesting that if you owned a major retailer with an established catalog model, plus a network of stores and storefronts to deliver catalog orders, PLUS a cash cow insurance company (Allstate), PLUS a broadly established payment network (Discover) in 1993, divesting yourself of those assets at that time is a particularly untimely thing to do. It's also reflective of not seeing the big picture.
The catalog operation hadn't been a big part of sears in a long time--maybe decades. Amazon's success didn't result from having the bide idea to be "the everything store." It was executing on it--and, by the way, making losses along the way that shareholders would likely never have tolerated in a mature retail chain. I'm not convinced that Sears had any particular unfair advantage as a retailer to dominate in ecommerce just because they had once been known for their catalog.
>stats and excel driven management
I think you can be pretty certain that any successful retailer is highly number-driven from picking sites to handling supply chains.