Re:The Decline of Sears
by dragonwriter on Saturday February 20, 2016 @09:04PM
(#11142954)
There has never been a state that even claimed to be unqualified Marxist, all the states that claimed something derived ultimately from Marxism have claimed descent through Leninism, which threw out the fundamental prerequisites for Marxism of a broad movement in an advanced capitalist state in favor of a system that was premised on an elite vanguard operating in a precapitalist state.
Socialist movements influenced by non-Leninist Marxism (though rarely as the sole Socialist influence) have been quite successful in the developed world, though they don't tend to set up one party states even where they are influential, again, because that's something more associated with the authoritarian paternalism of Leninist vanguardism than it does with non-Leninist Marxism.
So, its perhaps fair to say Leninism has been tested and failed; far less so for Marxism.
We could say it, but in fact, it has been claimed that no Marxist state has ever correctly implemented Marxism. "No true Scotsman" is a handy fallacy.
Non-falsifiability is a feature of every mature ideology.