News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Decline of Sears by douche on Saturday February 20, 2016 @10:24AM (#11140373)
I have to be careful buying tools from Sears now (which is really the only reason I go in there), because they've started selling cheap knock-off stuff under the Craftsman label, that isn't up to the old quality standards and doesn't have the Craftsman lifetime warranty on it.

I think the worst was a socket set I picked up, where the chrome was literally coming off in flakes after a couple months.

Re:The Decline of Sears by blt on Saturday February 20, 2016 @03:40PM (#11141844)
All Craftsman hand tools are all made in China now. My metric Craftsman wrenches are made in China and my SAE ones are made in the USA. The difference in quality is obvious. Not saying that Made In China == Low Quality, but in the case of Craftsman tools it's true. Plus it makes their "lifetime warranty" feel like a load of BS when the replacement for anything more than 10 years old is going to be vastly inferior to the original.

The middle market of hand tools has been gutted. If you're not buying top-of-the line stuff like Snap-On, Knipex, etc. you might as well just shop at Harbor Freight and save some money.

Re:The Decline of Sears by mc32 on Saturday February 20, 2016 @08:33PM (#11142868)
Protos are pretty good too. Made in Taiwan gearwrench are affordable and decent for the price.
Re:The Decline of Sears by pbreit on Saturday February 20, 2016 @09:28PM (#11143004)
Considering that Apple and others are able to get extremely high quality manufacturing out of China, it's a shame this isn't more widespread. I guess consumers don't really expect much better.
Re:The Decline of Sears by solipsism on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:34AM (#11143580)
Apple products are assembled in China. Manufacturing comes from all over the world.
Re:The Decline of Sears by labster on Saturday February 20, 2016 @04:25PM (#11142028)
I bought a wand-style garden sprayer with the Craftsman lifetime warranty about 5 years ago. I'm now on the 30th replacement. I have to be careful about the returns, so that I don't accidentally get one of the sprayers I had already returned as broken. They restock them sometimes.

The first one lasted about a year before breaking. Then they changed the design to "cheap Chinese chic", and they usually take 1-2 months before they start leaking. A new rubber washer helps at first, but then they start leaking inside the case.

I probably wouldn't bother with the returns if I didn't live so close to the Sears store, but the lifetime warranty is certainly no indicator of product quality.

Re:The Decline of Sears by sokoloff on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:48AM (#11140790)
I think all the chrome sockets with the Craftsman brand are still unlimited lifetime warranty.

In any case, I also noticed the downward shift in quality of Craftsman tools, corresponding with the time that the contract manufacturer was switched and a lot of production went offshore. Fortunately, I'd already mostly switched to buying second-hand SnapOn hand tools, and I have to say that while I was generally happy with the old USA Craftsman tools, I wish I'd have switched to SnapOn earlier.

The ratchets in particular are night-and-day better, IMO. Do yourself a favor and try one of the nice common SnapOn ratchets (a T72/TL72 or an F80). They're quite a bit more pleasurable to use, IMO. SnapOn stuff holds its value pretty well, which means it often gets pawned or sold when a mechanic goes out of business. I have bought maybe 5% of my SnapOn stuff new; most has been second/third hand and it's just as good and 30-40% the price.

Re:The Decline of Sears by douche on Saturday February 20, 2016 @12:43PM (#11141026)
Snap-on is good stuff, but it can be a little tricky finding a place that honors their warranty if you break something. I just give whatever it is to my Dad, who works in a plant that has a Snap-on sales rep swing by once a week, but without that connection, I wouldn't know where to go with it. Craftsman, at least you could find a Sears store to trade it in just about anywhere.
Re:The Decline of Sears by marincounty on Saturday February 20, 2016 @04:00PM (#11141936)
I've wondered about returning broken Snap-on tools, and glad I read your post. I have a box of broken tools, and I don't want to bother a driver. It's not that important. Tools have become so cheap.

Snap-on should go out of their way to honor their warranties though.

What Snap-on never really got--was that they are lucky to have customers, at what they charge for tools.

I don't blame the guys running around in trucks--that's a whole other franchise debacle. Snap-on should compensate them(franchise owners) for Any returned tools. Why--because that's what they promised when we bought their first overpriced tools.

If you are dead set on Snap-on, just buy the 3/8" metric, and inch ratchet set. I bought mine second hand. Everything else can be another brand.

I saw guys spend $40,000 on tools. A lot of them were too young, nor cared about ROI.

Never forget the Snap-on rep in automotive school. He was worse than a drug dealer. (I do understand his persistence. I don't think Snap-on makes it easy for their employees/franchise owners.)

Re:The Decline of Sears by gregpilling on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:00PM (#11143241)
I was a Snap On dealer for 6 years.

Dealers are all franchises, not 'drivers'. The warranty is usually under 2% of sales. If it goes higher than that, the management start to whine. Mine was almost never higher; the most expensive thing I replaced under warranty was a $10,000 engine analyzer.

Getting a dealer to warranty tools should not be considered a hassle for him if you do it at one of his stops. I would generally not go chase warranty - but if someone jumps on the truck with a broken tool I would replace it without thinking. Snap-on compensates the dealers 100% of cost of the tool, so it is not the dealer paying for it. He also gets a chance to sell you something new.

Lucky to have customers? Snap-on has 4000+ dealers in the USA, and each one services about 300 customers. Average sales for a truck is around $500,000 per year now with 35% gross margins. Lots of customers, way more than you would ever think. Some of my biggest customers were in weird locations, like a lawnmower place that had all giant tool boxes in them. A KRL1033 is a big bench toolbox and costs $11,000 for the EMPTY toolbox https://store.snapon.com/KRL1033-Series-Roll-Cabs-Roll-Cab-T... . I wrote 120 extended payment contracts in 1991, most of them for big toolboxes. I was #2 that year at the branch.

$40,000 is a lot of tools, but that is cheaper than some college educations these days with much higher residual value. My biggest single sale was $92,000.00 for a 2 man shop's insurance claim. That was 2 large boxes with hand and airtools in them, no equipment. Granted, they were my best customers and had the receipts to prove it. Insurance company pressured me for 10% off, but that was ok with me.

Your Snap-on dealer may have been persistent just to collect money. Dealers run a no-interest account for most of their 300 customers. The lions share of the job is collecting money, selling tools is easy. Collecting money is hard, especially from students. I ran about $50,000 over 150 customers. I know other dealers that would float $300,000 on the street, guys in Alaska and the other oil spots.

It was a good training business. I don't regret it, I made a lot of money. In 1991 I made $85,000 with only a high school education. I was 21 years old. I call it a training business because it is hard to expand. There is no practical way to hire employees besides having a complete second truck. Also, the more accounts you get sooner or later they want to cut your area. The change to franchising actually gave dealers more rights at that point. My area was cut 3 times in 6 years.

At the end of the day it is a service job, and we are servicing the needs of professional tool users, people that make their living with those tools. It is very competitive and I don't see anyway the service level could be kept up without the high prices and the current margins. The professionals need the service to function, the Snap-on dealer was also the one guy that you knew would have the special tools you needed to get that one thing apart. There is 12,000 items in the catalog and the basic wrenches and screwdrivers make up a small part of it. Most of the tool count is in special wrenches and sockets.

Re:The Decline of Sears by ars on Saturday February 20, 2016 @09:35PM (#11143026)
> I have a box of broken tools, and I don't want to bother a driver.

Why not? Isn't that their job? Especially with a box and not a single tool.

Re:The Decline of Sears by hga on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:46AM (#11140780)
Gaaah, I wish I could say I couldn't believe this, but e.g. http://www.craftsman.com/en_us/customer-care/warranty-inform... "Craftsman Hand Tools NOT labeled HAND TOOL FULL WARRANTY in warranty header"

Are only covered for 1 year, and of course you've got to provide proof of purchase.

They're insane.

Re:The Decline of Sears by sokoloff on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:50AM (#11140803)
I believe those limited warranty tools tend to be gardening tools and the like.

As far as I know, the Craftsman brand mechanics hand tools are still lifetime warranty. The 1 year term is for tools "not of metal construction".

Re:The Decline of Sears by hga on Saturday February 20, 2016 @04:36PM (#11142067)
You could well be right, I just spent several minutes at sears.com looking at socket sets and all that I looked at, including a number of the lowest, "only" 4 star rated ones, had lifetime warranties.

However, by giving any hand tool labeled Craftsman a less than lifetime warranty, they've done terrible damage to the brand, you shouldn't have to worry about this when shopping at Sears.

Re:The Decline of Sears by bliti on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:41AM (#11140757)
I stopped buying them about ten years ago. I now just buy the cheapest thing available for hand tools that have no special use. For powertools I stick to Hilti. Air-driven Snap-on. Specialty tools are purchased from Snap-on or Matco. Craftsman used to be a good brand, now its just a brand.