Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by rogerthatt on Saturday February 20, 2016 @06:25AM
(#11139711)
For those of us that aren't aware, do you know much about the instances where apple has unlocked phones in the past? I was not aware of this!
Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by osolo on Saturday February 20, 2016 @08:00AM
(#11139894)
It's been reported that Apple unlocked phones 70 times in the past. But all those instances were for phones with older versions of iOS that were pre-encryption.
Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by MaysonL on Saturday February 20, 2016 @11:05AM
(#11140591)
It's been falsely reported that Apple unlocked phones 70 times in the past. See Matthew Panzarino's article in TechCrunch: http://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/no-apple-has-not-unlocked-7...
Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by makecheck on Saturday February 20, 2016 @08:51AM
(#11140016)
No matter what kind of program I write, there seems to be some way for unexpected delays to occur.
If Apple were somehow forced to perform this “burdensome” activity, they should take their sweet time and claim one unexpected software/hardware issue after another. Why not? It is entirely plausible (lots of precedence) and since they are by definition building something they did not have before, they could even say they have no experience with what they are trying to build so they can’t know how long it would take. :)
Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by cmurf on Saturday February 20, 2016 @12:27PM
(#11140971)
Given how hard both parties are hitting this particular punching bag, it's reasonable it ends up at the Supreme Court. While a 4-4 tie at the Court isn't certain, it makes estimation of how the court of appeals will decide the case more important since that decision would stand if SCOTUS splits.
Re:Justice Dept.’s Latest Legal Filing in Apple Case
by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday February 20, 2016 @06:34AM
(#11139731)
> that Apple has unlocked phones in other cases
With or without whole system encryption?
In reading the document it seemed to me that the outcome may hinge on whether compliance would be considered "burdensome" to Apple. The government asserts that modifying the software (for this one instance and no other) is more or less trivial, therefore Apple really has no grounds for refusal.
Some comments on HN have suggested the software isn't so simple to produce, but not something I know enough about to speculate. Perhaps Apple's reply to the court will shed some light on this aspect. Fascinating to watch this chess match play out.
I'm guessing in the end the court order will stand and Apple will need to comply. Maybe Apple surmises the same. It's reasonable to believe their protests will garner ongoing public sympathy while cooperating with the FBI under compulsion of the court.