News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Most People Think Memorizing Historical Facts is Usel... by ugh on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @08:23PM (#1113935)
The history classes I had (post, let's say, eighth grade; I’m from Germany) were all about the “why”. The credo was not to even bother remembering historical facts unless they help you explain why something happened. I always hated remembering facts. But I always really loved history. It wasn’t about facts, it was about explaining why something happened (with the facts as your tool) and finding out whether some explanations are better or more plausible than others.

Remembering just facts is no fun if you can’t use them for anything.

(The “whys” of history are more than cute little stories about individuals as this article makes it sound, though. Explanations can include economic data, statistics, maps, laws, newspaper articles, cartoons and all kinds of documents.)

PS, history as taught in the United States can’t be that bad. I just finished listening to a lecture about Germany prior to the First World War by Margaret Anderson (Department of History UC Berkeley – http://history.berkeley.edu/faculty/Anderson/ – the lecture is available as a podcast – oh, the joys of the internet) and it pretty much echoed exactly all the things we discussed in the last two years in school. It was pretty nostalgic all around.

Re:Why Most People Think Memorizing Historical Facts is Usel... by lmkg on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @09:05PM (#1114003)
You're bringing up a world-class institution of higher learning, whereas the article is talking about average, run-of-the-mill education. History taught at the upper-college levels can be pretty good. History taught in public high schools, not so much. There are some good teachers out there, so YMMV, but history, as well as math, have a habit of being short-changed by memorization-focused learning and testing. Not even because it's easy to teach, but because it's easy to grade.
Re:Why Most People Think Memorizing Historical Facts is Usel... by ugh on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @05:51AM (#1114610)
Bad teachers can turn interesting explanations into boring lists of facts.

And your schools can't be that far behind universities when it comes to teaching quality, can they? Considering that teaching quality (contrary to depth and detail of knowledge of those teaching and other advantages of higher education) is the one thing were at least in my experience schools are sometimes even better as universities.