Re:Why Apple's fight with the FBI could have reverberations ...
by txru on Friday February 19, 2016 @08:03PM
(#11138055)
I'm willing to believe that you're right.
I think, though, that the government will take this as a sign that they need to never have the need to ask this question again. The demand that encrypted communications devices have some back door wasn't some capricious whim this year: it's been brewing for years, and only accelerated with the widespread adoption of distributing encrypted operating systems.
While I agree that this particular request is similar to demanding that citizens (or corporations), quarter troops, I think it's an error to look too far outside of the realm of communications with regard to the Constitution.
This goes FAR beyond that. This is coercing a company to do something beyond simply turning over information. There is a big difference in turning over something which already exists and compelling a company to perform work to create something which does not yet exist.
Picture this if served to a small company. Even if the company was compensated for the work, what happens if it takes all of the company resources over 3 months? Will the government compensate for lost clients? Will the government compensate for lost opportunities?
This kind of government demand is much more like quartering troops (government compulsion to perform an action), and we know full well what the Founding Fathers thought of that.