Re:America's 250th DNA exoneration: How often is wrong perso...
by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:35AM
(#1114488)
You realize what you're asking for here is that the prosecutor decide who is innocent and who to fully prosecute, i.e. who is guilty. That completely, or at least partially, negates the idea that the jury of your peers should do the deciding. As soon as the lawyers start making those kinds of choices, it's not (all) in the jury's hands anymore.
Perhaps you might suggest the prosecution is in the best position to know. Perhaps you might suggest that if the prosecution is 80% certain of innocence, that clearly the defendant should be found innocent. But, according to our law, (unless I grossly misunderstand them) it is not his choice to make.
In the event a prosecutor is pretty sure the defendant is innocent AND that they can probably get a conviction, I'd like to see them abandon their case (I don't know if this allowed, but they could certainly argue to a jury or judge that the person is innocent), but I understand that it's not required, and I don't consider them evil unless they go further and try to block appeals, or conceal exculpatory evidence.