News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by waterlesscloud on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @01:42PM (#1112864)
So they want to duplicate what Facebook does? Great for them, I suppose, but why would I as a user go to it? Any feature they add, FB can add. And FB already has the graph I want.
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by afterburner on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @02:38PM (#1113027)
Easy: I don't want to check two things. I only want to check Gmail. I don't want to bother with Facebook, my online life is not Facebook-centric, it's Gmail-centric, and Facebook is merely a drag I occasionally put up with.
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by mark_h on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @03:42PM (#1113242)
This, exactly. My only real concern is that my inbox could get drowned, but my cursory skim that would only be a danger if posted a lot yourself (and got a lot of replies).

I wonder though if we're really that representative? It reminds me a bit of friendfeed which I loved, and no-one else I knew used.

Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by afterburner on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @04:10PM (#1113327)
From the video it looks like it's a separate label, just under Inbox.

I have several friends that similarly could not care less about Facebook, but more that actually do care. To be honest, even with great integration, it will still take a critical mass of people in social groupings to actually care. And not everyone I know uses Gmail as their primary email. Although most do (which is impressive).

Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by mark_h on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @05:48PM (#1113602)
It's a separate label, but replies go to your inbox (from the video, again).

Agreed on the need for a critical mass, but integrating with gmail suggests that it's a bit more of a serious push for them, as opposed to say wave which looks a bit more like a "wait and see" play. I need to read more about it; I'm still waiting for a federated set of protocols to get widespread adoption, a-la http://diso-project.org/ (I have a /lot/ of links collected of similar attempts :))

Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by adamhowell on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @02:01PM (#1112926)
Before I left I was asked to work on several Facebook app competitors using OpenSocial -- supposedly because of "executive pressure" that was, then, based on the positive buzz around Facebook apps. I was disappointed to be so directly experiencing the Silicon Valley echo chamber.

But, they've been wanting to use Gmail as the center of everyone's social network for awhile. I guess this is the first step.

Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by araneae on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @02:16PM (#1112962)
Well, they already have Google profiles. This Buzz thing just sounds like extra features on top of Google profiles. In fact, I posted on Facebook yesterday about how I was sick of it and did anyone want to join me on Google profiles. No one did, and mostly people hadn't heard of it. But I definitely see the appeal of attaching everything to my e-mail address.

Also, a great deal of the appeal of Facebook, for me, is as an address book. But all the people I contact are in my GMail contacts list, and it's annoying to manually enter in things like their phone number or address. Now with Google profiles I won't have to look that stuff up on Facebook, because it should be in their Google profile.

Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by jlees on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @03:44PM (#1113244)
Attaching everything to my email address would be great if I could just change my primary gmail username. I'm a bit fed up of it now. I have secondary accounts (which are painful enough to manage in the light of Buzz etc), but I don't want to lose access to 7 years of email and contacts either. The only solution I can think of is setting up a new address and a forwarder...
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by grinich on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @06:52PM (#1113742)
If you have a some patience, you can copy all of your mail through IMAP. You can also export your contacts and filters.
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by iron_ball on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @03:07PM (#1113139)
My Android phone automatically syncs contact information from Facebook, so it's not like Google isn't open to that. I understand that Google's right hand doesn't always know what the left is doing, though.
Re:Live Google event about Google Buzz by potatolicious on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @07:46PM (#1113855)
They do somewhat more I think - from the brief demo video it looks like content embedding is performed much better - both in terms of UI and functionality.

Also, Google's strengths in recommendation generation may make your "status stream" more relevant and interesting than Facebook's. Time will tell on this part.