Re:America's 250th DNA exoneration: How often is wrong perso...
by Estragon on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @01:15PM
(#1112796)
That reasoning would only hold if you surveyed the DNA of everyone in that city, which is never the case.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:America's 250th DNA exoneration: How often is wrong perso...
by barrkel on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1112852)
No, you don't need to survey everyone in the city. Assume you instituted a DNA search, whereby you went from district to district and tested DNA until you got a match, the chance would still be only 1 in three, under the same assumptions.
And government policy here in the UK seems to be to retain the DNA of everyone that comes into contact with the state, so I expect it's only a matter of time until there will be chance collisions resulting in incorrect convictions.
Re:America's 250th DNA exoneration: How often is wrong perso...
by Estragon on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @11:45PM
(#1114236)
OK, it only applies if you survey everyone in the city until you get a match. Same difference. Yes, things may be heading in that direction. That was not the original argument, though.