News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why are comment trees not collapsible yet? by krapp on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:42PM (#11121662)
Actually, dang has mentioned that collapsible comments are on the way (eventually), so at least in that case the staff doesn't appear to believe it would have too negative an effect on the community. And if it winds up being implemented in javascript, most HN users probably won't see a difference to begin with, because they'll refuse to turn it on, and post a thousand threads ranting about it.

>Collapsed comments are usually ignored, because people are too lazy to dig that deep, that means some really good conversation might get buried.

I kind of see this as a feature. The deeper into a subtree you go, the more tangential the conversation becomes, and the less likely it is that it will be relevant or interesting to the community at large. Willingness to follow a comment tree shows intellectual curiosity and investment in the conversation.

With a completely open tree, like Hacker News has now, most comments are noise to most people.

Re:Ask HN: Why are comment trees not collapsible yet? by NetStrikeForce on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:03AM (#11151712)
I think Slash supported all that already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slash_(CMS)

My point being, HN tried (and IMHO succeeded at it) to be something different and these little things might have helped to become what it is. If we keep moving to support all of Slash's features, HN might be doomed to become Slashdot.

Re:Ask HN: Why are comment trees not collapsible yet? by krapp on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:47PM (#11156627)
Are we really "moving to support all of Slash's features" with folding comments? It's hardly a radical feature - most comment systems support it in some form, and many users are already running plugins for it on HN. I don't see anyone arguing that the Hacker News Enhancement Suite is threatening to doom us all.

Vouching up dead comments was potentially a much more volatile change but it seems to have worked out for the positive. I also remember people complaining that Show HN was killing the site literally on the day it started, yet it seems to have become an accepted part of the culture. What makes Hacker News unique is its connection to YCombinator and Paul Graham. Without that, it's little more than a poorly designed Reddit clone.