News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by HillRat on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @10:13AM (#11118315)
If the wellness program is offered as part of a group health plan, then the wellness-plan provider is a business associate of a covered entity under HIPAA, and PHI protection applies. So in these cases, the employer cannot have access to individual employees' health information and, more to the point, they usually don't want it -- they're trying to cut overall costs, not individual employees.

Having said that, I do think that more robust legislative firewalls are needed to prevent companies from trying to push the envelope in accessing individual employees' records (HIPAA controls covered entities' actions, but not employers').

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by 6stringmerc on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @12:37PM (#11119564)
Caveat: In my experience, I've been subjected to a phone call from a Registered Nurse who reviewed my personal health records and called to ask me to switch to a cheaper medication because the company was going through some financial difficulty. I'm 100% not making this up. Your assertion that a company doesn't want personal health information of individual employees is one that I do not agree with.

If a company can eliminate the 5% of people driving XX% of the premium cost - through cancer, major surgeries, etc - then it stands to reason they would undertake that method of reducing overhead.

The employer itself may not have access, but the party they hired may have access, and I do agree that robust legislative firewalls and significant jail-time for violators should be a national priority.

Or, in other words, I very much disagree "Wellness Programs" are actually concerned with wellness (no assistance with dietary materials, gym memberships, incentives, etc) and should be portrayed as "Health Cost Containment Programs" which is significantly more honest.

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by bduerst on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @02:02PM (#11120303)
Who was this RN working for exactly? Your PCP? Your insurance company? A broker? A third party?

I doubt they are employed at the company you work at, meaning your employer isn't look at your health record.

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by st3v3r on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @02:09PM (#11120353)
Employed directly? Maybe not. Employed by a company the employer asked to look into reducing health plan costs? Most likely. And just as creepy and scummy.
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by 6stringmerc on Thursday February 18, 2016 @04:25PM (#11129451)
I believe your scenario as described would be an accurate assessment of what I perceived to be happening. As in, a hired firm that could legally review records as medical professionals and then make that type of call. I'm a well-educated health consumer so I knew the product I was being requested to use was actually more risky long-term to my personal health, which I thoroughly explained at probably too loud a volume to be considered polite during the course of the call.
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by bduerst on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:24PM (#11120995)
Or it could be their PCP's RN asking them to switch their ongoing Rx to a generic, because recent updates to their health plan means a higher co-pay or deductible.

This happens more than you realize, and doesn't mean their employer violated their privacy, which is why I ask.

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by st3v3r on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:42PM (#11121670)
Then they would have introduced themselves as such.
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by bduerst on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @05:01PM (#11121801)
Then it's an easy question to answer, isn't it? Any more insights into their phone conversation, st3v3r?

Edit: I knew I recognized you, s73v3r - https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=s73v3r

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @12:37PM (#11119561)
The problem is that you do have employers wanting to target individual employees and that just because something is illegal doesn't mean it won't happen. An employer could use this to identify what employees are about to become pregnant and then find reasons to fire them. And given that being fired is likely to change their chance of choosing to become pregnant, it becomes significantly harder to prove this was an illegal targeted attack instead of a justified firing of an employee who was violating policy (and given how policies are written, workplace policies are treated like laws these days where everyone is violating some policies and they are only selectively enforced). Add in that this is most likely to be deployed against lower income people if it is deployed, and that those it is deployed against will be in a very poor condition to fight back (hiring a lawyer right after losing a job isn't something most can afford), you have a nasty discrimination disaster ready to happen (or in reality, ready to be made worse than it currently is).
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by Retric on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @12:44PM (#11119632)
Policies that are 'selectively' enforced have limited value as protection from a lawsuit.
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @01:00PM (#11119780)
If it can be proven that there is no reason behind the selective enforcement and if it can be shown that it is selectively enforced. The thing is, the people most likely to be a victim of these policies are the least likely to afford the discovery to prove this, to say nothing of the other side effects (such as being black listed from an industry).
Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @02:38PM (#11120589)
> If the wellness program is offered as part of a group health plan, then the wellness-plan provider is a business associate of a covered entity under HIPAA, and PHI protection applies. But whether that prevents disclosure depends on what specific consent is given as part of opting-in to the offered wellness plan.

As I understand, these plans often include consent for fairly extensive information sharing with employers as part of the opt-in paperwork (and that that is a big part of the reason that they are offered.)

Re:Bosses Harness Big Data to Predict Which Workers Might Ge... by braythwayt on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @11:10AM (#11118792)
Thank you for the elucidation. This is the kind of quality reply that makes HN great.