If a company can eliminate the 5% of people driving XX% of the premium cost - through cancer, major surgeries, etc - then it stands to reason they would undertake that method of reducing overhead.
The employer itself may not have access, but the party they hired may have access, and I do agree that robust legislative firewalls and significant jail-time for violators should be a national priority.
Or, in other words, I very much disagree "Wellness Programs" are actually concerned with wellness (no assistance with dietary materials, gym memberships, incentives, etc) and should be portrayed as "Health Cost Containment Programs" which is significantly more honest.
I doubt they are employed at the company you work at, meaning your employer isn't look at your health record.
This happens more than you realize, and doesn't mean their employer violated their privacy, which is why I ask.
Edit: I knew I recognized you, s73v3r - https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=s73v3r
As I understand, these plans often include consent for fairly extensive information sharing with employers as part of the opt-in paperwork (and that that is a big part of the reason that they are offered.)
Having said that, I do think that more robust legislative firewalls are needed to prevent companies from trying to push the envelope in accessing individual employees' records (HIPAA controls covered entities' actions, but not employers').